Comments on: Did Polycarp Meet John the Apostle? https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999 Announcing appearances, publications, and analysis of questions historical, philosophical, and political by author, philosopher, and historian Richard Carrier. Wed, 28 Oct 2026 21:21:16 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-45780 Wed, 28 Oct 2026 21:21:16 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-45780 In reply to Ben.

I cannot fathom how even you think that’s a coherent argument.

We were talking about modern religious experiences, to which I replied with the Outsider Test for Faith (abundant facts entail those experiences are nondeterminative of reality and maximally likely to be false). You then change the subject back to the historicity of Jesus which wasn’t what I was commenting on. So your comment is a non sequitur.

When we return to what you were supposed to be responding to, my point about modern religious experience being unreliable, your analogy has no discernible relevance and appears to indicate you literally can’t comprehend the very simple argument that was just made and thus literally don’t know what you are talking about now.

]]>
By: Ben https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-45760 Wed, 28 Oct 2026 17:58:27 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-45760 In reply to Richard Carrier.

Your personal experience can neither prove nor disprove the historicity of Christ or the accounts of the apostles. Your argument can be summarized something like this: I met a nice Austrian, so Hitler can’t have been such a bad person after all.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-43035 Fri, 23 Jan 2026 15:53:04 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-43035 In reply to Anthony A TINUFA.

No. I am delusion free.

But I had the same experience with the Tao. Which proves you did not experience anything supernaturally real, any more than I did. You just were jolted into rethinking your life. You don’t need a celestial conspiracy theory to do that. No one does.

]]>
By: Anthony A TINUFA https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-43025 Thu, 22 Jan 2026 16:39:10 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-43025 In reply to Richard Carrier.

I was a sinner up till March 1992 but I met one man in that same March and preached Christ to me and I repented from my sin. From that moment my life of sinfulness ended – no more lying, fighting etc . My question to you is Do you believe Jesus Died and rose again on the third 3rd day Sir.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-41746 Thu, 18 Sep 2025 19:31:11 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-41746 In reply to Crystal.

Certainly not. Look at how routinely Christian leaders and apologists lie and fabricate even still now. They were even more rampant liars back then.

Almost all Christian Gospels, Acts, and Epistles, some hundreds of examples, were forged; indeed less than 10% of Christian literature was honestly produced, the rest was fake. And their polemics were full of slanders and lies. It was the normal mode of any cult to act this way, and it worked because the people they want believe all the lies, and the ones who don’t they attack as sinners and the damned and enemies of Christ (see 2 Peter 1–2 for an example). Other examples: How To Fabricate History: The Example of Eusebius on Alexandrian Christianity and The Rain Miracle of Marcus Aurelius: A Case Study in Christian Lies. The problem has been extensively documented in studies recently by Markus Vinzent and Robyn Walsh and others.

Ancient Christianity was a fringe cult and behaved like one. It is more like Mormonism or Scientology today: built on lying at its basic foundation, and thus constructed out of rhetoric to denounce anyone who does not believe the lies, and reward anyone who does.

As to why religions do this: primarily (1) money, (2) power, and (3) social control (religion, like war, is politics by other means: if you want to change society, you have to lie about God wanting you to change it the way you want to; this is a global anthropological phenomenon: see chapter 10 of Not the Impossible Faith).

Secondarily, because people suffering mass delusions have to lie constantly to maintain their beliefs against the evidence (MAGA and QAnon today are textbook examples). This is called cognitive dissonance and it has been a documented feature of all religions for quite some time now. For examples of why this happens see Establishing the Biblical Literalism of Early Christians and How Did Christianity Switch to a Historical Jesus?.

Thus, it is the people who question the lies who get vilified and expelled, not the liars. The liars get money, support, promotions, and power. Again, observe how this works in the MAGA universe (examples, examples; and example, example; and so on). It worked the same way within the Christian universe then.

]]>
By: Crystal https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-41742 Thu, 18 Sep 2025 17:53:54 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-41742 What would any of these people have gained from spreading lies about the teachings of Jesus? I mean in their time? What would they have gained (other than people possibly following the teachings) it seems more reasonable to me that they would more than likely (like many others throughout history) would have been ostracized and cut off from the society they knew and also possibly killed for their “spreading lies”.
Does this not make more sense?

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-41502 Sun, 24 Aug 2025 15:39:34 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-41502 In reply to robert.

None of that is a coherent response to the argument in my article.

Just ignoring what I say is not going to generate any evidence I’m “lying” about anything. To get to that you need to identify a sentence that is (a) false (that hasn’t even been done here) and (b) that I know or must know is false (which is not even being attempted here).

So these interlocutors neither know what the word “lying” means nor what an “argument” is or how to identify its premises and formula so as to respond to either.

]]>
By: robert https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-41497 Sun, 24 Aug 2025 09:15:48 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-41497 Dr Carrier, on reddit, an Xtian apologist in response to you said

Carrier:
He says current legends claim Polycarp knew John. That’s it.

Xtian:
Nope. “I can even describe the place where the blessed Polycarp used to sit and discourse.”
Polycarp] would speak of his familiar intercourse with John”
Irenaeus got this directly from Polycarp.

Carrier:
He never says Polycarp himself said this

Xtian:
“[Polycarp] would speak of his familiar intercourse with John”

someone responded :

it appears to me that you didn’t bother to read the responses. carrier thinks that what you quoted contradicts what iraenues said. carrier seems to be saying that it went from “asiatic churches” as the source to, “full-blown legend that Irenaeus himself actually heard Polycarp say all these things as a boy, the very thing Irenaeus conspicuously did not say in his own actual writings—as we just saw”

what did we see? to quote carrier again : Notice the trick. He has shell-gamed you. He mentions seeing him once. But when it comes time to say he “taught the things which he had learned from the apostles” he credits the source as “all the Asiatic Churches.” Not himself. So he has actually not said Irenaeus heard Polycarp say this. Irenaeus is saying he personally believes Polycarp was teaching what he learned from the Apostles because the churches in Irenaeus’s day claim this. You’ve been duped.

Xtian replied :
it appears to me that you didn’t bother to read the responses.

Yes. Reading comments on blogs by crank conspiracy theorists is not something I usually waste my time on, especially since I had already showed Carrier to be lying about everything. Which is normal for him. Facts don’t really matter to him. All that matters is repeating his conspiracy theory.

The quotes I gave are clear. Carrier is lying.

https://old.reddit.com/r/DebateReligion/comments/1mu4tmt/the_historical_jesus_is_not_the_figure_worshipped/na4qiza/?context=3

so what is going on here?

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-39267 Tue, 22 Oct 2024 18:28:42 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-39267 In reply to Dennis.

It’s not especially.

First, all ancient names meant things. So there is no way to argue “this name had a meaning, therefore it isn’t real.” Indeed names can even be self-chosen or imputed nicknames. To identify a fictional name requires more evidence than this.

Second, Irenaeus is not a reliable narrator and probably not always honest, so it is reasonable to question what he says about himself. But we can’t translate that suspicion into a certainty. The letter of Irenaeus does clearly look like a forgery (and a bad one at that); but his own statements do seem to be so carefully phrased as to suggest he is telling the truth literally, just in such a way as to give some readers false impressions. I discuss this already above. But, of course, he might also be lying.

Third, Polycarp’s epistle may be a forgery, but I see no particular reason to think so, and as it contains no evidence of the things being claimed, it still leaves those claims in doubt.

Fourth, Simon Magus is someone whose existence can be doubted (his contextual invention in Acts suggests fiction; and everything else later written about him is fabulous to the point of ridiculous); but we don’t have that kind of evidence for Cerdo or Papias.

Fifth, Papias is quoted by a number of different authors, demonstrating an actual text did exist. It’s unlikely Irenaeus fabricated an entire book under a fake name just to occasionally quote it (if he did, he’d make it a far more useful trove of data to quote than it appears to have been). It’s more likely the book independently existed for him (and many others) to quote.

]]>
By: Dennis https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15999#comment-39230 Sun, 13 Oct 2024 16:36:43 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=15999#comment-39230 Dr. Carrier, first time visit your blog and want to ask you this question.

Iranaeue probably never met Polycarp as you mentioned. Perhaps, Polycarp’s claim he was the disciple of John is also fabrication narrative from Iranaeus? I don’t find Polycarp’s epistle to Philippians looks authenticity. Probably later forgery.

Iraneus mentions name Papias and Cerdo. Papias is well known for testimony who wrote Mark and Matthew. But I am thinking Papias is not real existed person but his name in Greek is ‘duck’, which symbolize ‘faithful’. His fragments are all fabricated by Iranaeus also, I think.

And about Cerdo, he is explicitly can see fake character deceived Marcion to join in his heresy. Cerdo also means in Greek ‘profit’ which Iranaeus tried to claim Marcion is depraved person like Simon Magus. This theme derive to Tertullian, he create narrative, Marcion donated 200,000 sesterces to church of Rome.

Is my question and analysis sound plausible?

]]>