Comments on: Things Fall Apart Only When You Check: The Main Reason the Historicity of Jesus Continues to Be Believed https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689 Announcing appearances, publications, and analysis of questions historical, philosophical, and political by author, philosopher, and historian Richard Carrier. Sat, 22 Nov 2025 17:03:14 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-42231 Sat, 22 Nov 2025 17:03:14 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-42231 In reply to Femi.

I assume you meant TGD (The God Delusion).

But yes, that’s my take, too. It’s not as awful as everyone makes out; it suits its purpose. The mistake is when people treat it as anything more than a colloquial summary and not a precise academic case. Anyone using Dawkins as an excuse not to read the formal academic atheist literature he is merely briefing is the one in the wrong. I understand people’s frustration with Dawkins making that tactic easier; I just don’t think they should react that way, since bridge-texts like his are necessary and useful. The correct reaction should be to constantly attack the theists treating Dawkins as the best argument and the end-text, and not as the over-brief intro-text.

]]>
By: Femi https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-42200 Wed, 12 Nov 2025 17:10:41 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-42200 In reply to Richard Carrier.

TDG is an easily accessible book written by a scientist for a popular audience. I first read it as a lapsing believer, and while I recognised some of the strawmanning that it engaged in, the general arguments did seem to be sound – that there are better explanations for reality and existence than whatever is proffered in religious texts, that there’s significant evidence indicating that religions are man-made. Dawkins’ goal was to try to make atheism/agnosticism/questioning the claims made by proponents of established religions, more mainstream – he succeeded in that goal I think.

Apologetics can be abstruse and can take on (in the minds of the less informed) the quality of arguing “the number of angels that can fit on a pinhead”, I think that’s when the big guns like yourself can come out with the stuff to beat their best arguments – a lot of which would fly over the heads of lay people like myself.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-39649 Wed, 11 Dec 2024 17:11:11 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-39649 In reply to Luke.

This is indeed discussed in some detail in my original study. Revelation is treated briefly in ch. 7 only because it is too late and vague to alter any likelihoods, but your methodological point is discussed extensively in Ch. 11.

Revelation isn’t about the life of Jesus, but the future. So we don’t expect any references to a historical Jesus there, even if there was a historical Jesus. It’s mere luck that the author just happened by chance to add a passing reference (otherwise irrelevant to any point he had to make) that Jesus was crucified in Jerusalem.

Of course that could be an interpolation (mainstream scholars have long argued for a redactional history behind Revelation), but as there is no evidence for that specifically being the case, it’s not relevant to the analytical point that the likelihood of such a line in Revelation is quite low; it just happens to be no lower on either theory (as Revelation riffs on Matthew and thus is aware of historicization, so the line is as likely whether Jesus existed or not). It thus has no effect on posterior probability.

This is not the same condition as many specific locations in Paul’s letters (and in Hebrews and 1 Clement), where mentioning matters relating to the ministry and life of Jesus are not only expected but often crucial to some point or argument they are making; and likewise generally, to the interests of their correspondents altogether, e.g. the historical Jesus is precisely what they should be asking Paul about or arguing over such that he would have to intervene and address them. This is actually discussed in detail in Chapter 11 of On the Historicity of Jesus (the entire opening section is about this methodological point; and the following sections give many ensuing examples).

]]>
By: Luke https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-39639 Mon, 09 Dec 2024 16:46:50 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-39639 Two points I would like to get your thoughts on. I’ve never really seen these points addressed or brought up (even by historicists!)

First, Revelation is basically just as sparse on details about the historical Jesus as Paul’s letters, Hebrews and 1 Clement. Even before the apocalyptic imagery begins, chapters 1-3 still contain no mention of Jesus’ earthly life or ministry. The author only acknowledges learning about Jesus through revelation from the Heavenly Jesus. And yet, we know the author of Revelation thought Jesus lived an earthly life because he mentions that he was crucified on earth in Revelation 11:8. Even there, the details are lacking. It’s just a passing reference, “where the Lord was crucified”. This has led me to think that the silence and lack of explicit details in the other Christian epistles are not nearly as damning as is sometimes argued.

Paul, Hebrews, 1 Clement only ever acknowledge that Jesus was celestial after his death and exaltation. Paul talks about meeting, “the Lord in the air”, and awaiting the “son from Heaven” in 1 Thessalonians, but it’s clear he’s referring to the exalted, resurrected Jesus in those verses. Those verses don’t indicate what he thought of the mortal Jesus. Hebrews refers to Jesus as the celestial High Priest, but also says Jesus was made the High Priest after his time of suffering during the “days of his flesh”, and at one point says that Jesus “entered into Heaven itself” (which is peculiar wording if they thought he was in the celestial sphere already as a mortal).

None of this would be unlikely at all if they’re referring to a human being who ascended to Heaven after a mortal life on earth.

I was as brief as I could be while still making these points. But I would appreciate your thoughts. I don’t remember seeing any historicist ever make these points before.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-38710 Mon, 12 Aug 2024 14:31:57 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-38710 In reply to Peter Boel Troelsen.

I already have, in the study they are supposed to be responding to. Their error is the same as I identify in Ch. 6.5. “The Alternative Class Objection” in On the Historicity of Jesus. I will first be submitting a formal paper pointing this out; then do a show or two about it (I’ve been asked by Godless Engineer by MythVision); and blog it once I get the formal reply accepted.

]]>
By: Peter Boel Troelsen https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-38706 Sun, 11 Aug 2024 23:57:35 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-38706 How do you respond to Gregor & Hansen’s critique of your identification of Raglan heroes and thereby your prior probability?

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-37606 Thu, 28 Mar 2024 14:12:03 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-37606 In reply to ou812invu.

I wouldn’t have time. But feel free to report on it here.

]]>
By: ou812invu https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-37603 Wed, 27 Mar 2024 23:13:16 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-37603 Dr. Carrier I’m curious if you’ve registered for an will be attending Bart Ehrman’s free new course titled
“Did Peter Hate Paul?”

It will be broadcasting live this weekend and if you can’t make it they will be sending you a link to see the replay (if you registered for the course). I think it would be cool if you attended and even submitted a question or disagreement during the course (if you had any). It would be interesting also to see if he would be willing to engage you on a topic that is outside the heated mythicism area (which he refuses to engage you on).

You can register for the course by click on the link below.
http://www.tinyurl.com/BartHate

I’m assuming that it is an auto-registration type process so I expect you would be accepted like anyone else.
But you could always try to sign up using an anonymous account just to be safe. LOL

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-37601 Wed, 27 Mar 2024 20:35:44 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-37601 In reply to ou812invu.

I consider this just semantics. What the word “divine” means can vary by context and plenty of existing valences fit Mark’s Jesus. So I don’t see anything shady in Ehrman’s language. What he means by the difference (being merely a divine being vs. being literally God) he has adequately explained in his book on the subject. On which you can read my review: Bart Ehrman on How Jesus Became God. I think in fact that might clear some things up for you.

But as to Mark specifically:

First, I don’t know if Ehrman adopts the view that Mark thinks Jesus was a pre-existent being. That’s not the same thing as being a divine being. Plenty of divine beings begin as divine mortals, not pre-existent incarnated entities. Ehrman can simply mean “empowered by god, demigod, superhuman,” which literally matches what Mark depicts.

Second, even if Ehrman adopts my view that Mark does indeed know Jesus is a pre-existent being, remember two things: (1) Mark is reifying Paul’s theology (Mark’s Use of Paul’s Epistles), which definitely placed Jesus as a pre-existent sub-god incarnate; and (2) Mark is writing to obscure that actual theology behind allegory (as Mark just-as-covertly warns us in Mark 4:9–13), a device not uncommon in religion generally (see Elements 13 and 14 in Ch. 4 of OHJ).

So you should not read Mark literally. By omitting explicit references to Jesus’s primordial origins he is not conveying his belief that he had none. He is concealing it.

This is why demons already know who Jesus really is, but he doesn’t want them to tell anyone (reifying into narrative 1 Cor. 2:7). It’s not coherent (why wouldn’t those demons then have warned Satan off and thus stopped the crucifixion?), but mythology rarely is. There are plenty of implausible and contradictory storylines in Mark (like cursing a fig tree for not bearing figs out of season, or letting a horde of demons destroy an entire town’s livelihood by drowning thousands of pigs—and no one getting upset about this). Because it’s not history. It’s mythology.

Hence Mark preserves Pauline ideas only in symbol: Jesus is God’s adopted son (reified by a mythical baptism scene), and his flesh is inhabited by a Spirit before that happens (mythically signifying the incarnation of a pre-existent Spirit); which also leaves Jesus when his body dies (the crucifixion scene has him “expire,” lit. exiting the pneuma, exepneusen). None of this can be confidently read that way by itself (that’s the point of concealing the truth behind parable, per Mark 4); but in conjunction with the knowledge that Mark is using stories to convey Paul’s ideas, it becomes apparent enough.

But again, Mark does not mean any of this literally. Mark does not think Jesus was just a schmo until a bird from outer space flew into his body and took over. The scene is not meant as history. It is meant as symbol, a tale signifying deeper truths figuratively, not literally.

Like the fig tree scene. Mark does not actually think Jesus was a lunatic who once cursed a fig tree for not bearing figs when it wasn’t even supposed to be bearing figs. The fig tree represents the Jewish temple cult, the season remark represents God’s decision that the season for that has ended, the cursing of the tree symbolizes God’s destruction and razing of Jerusalem (through the agency of the Romans). And so on. (All as discussed in OHJ, author index, “Hamerton-Kelly.”)

]]>
By: ou812invu https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/25689#comment-37600 Wed, 27 Mar 2024 20:10:02 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=25689#comment-37600 Dr. Carrier I was listening to a podcast with Bart Ehrman. He was talking about and defending the idea that the author of Mark didn’t portray Jesus as God. Something I think you agree with. But he did say of Mark’s idea of Jesus, that he thought Jesus was “devine”.

I can see how someone might take that as double-talk, at least based on my understanding of proper use of the word devine. I understand it to mean “of or relating to a god”. I know people will sometimes describe someone as being “devine”, but they are obviously and knowingly being superfluous in those instances.

What do you make of Ehrman describing Mark’s potrayal of Jesus that way? To be clear I’m not asking of your opinion as to whether Jesus should be described that way (as being God or even God like).
I’m asking whether you think his use of that term to describe how Mark saw Jesus (in his stories) as being devine is accurate, and if so what is your understanding of the word if to mean something other than God or like God?

]]>