Comments on: Did the Rapture Already Happen!? No. Nor Will It Ever. https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318 Announcing appearances, publications, and analysis of questions historical, philosophical, and political by author, philosopher, and historian Richard Carrier. Sat, 14 Mar 2026 16:01:04 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-40370 Mon, 14 Apr 2025 19:05:24 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-40370 In reply to Shaikh.

The Revolution Cult thesis in anthropology proposes (with examples like the Cargo Cults and the Ghost Dance movement) that this happens when you have a primituve “native” culture dominated by a more advanced imperial culture: the result is transformative apocalypticism. This is why this was all the rage in Roman occupied Judea. And why it is all the rage in the ultraconservative wings of American Christian culture, which perceives itself as the “native” culture and the extremely sophisticated progressive culture dominating it (the “deep state,” a.k.a. modernity). The trigger is its decline (similar to the Zakaria hypothesis: as religions face declining adherents and respect, they become increasingly radicalized, eventually into violence).

That is why ISIS was an Islamic doomsday cult. Its worldview is dying, they have no realistic power or control, so they will mass from all over the world to fight an apocalyptic war to assuage their cognitive dissonance.

]]>
By: Shaikh https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-40366 Sun, 13 Apr 2025 20:45:37 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-40366 Honestly I wish the rapture was real and that I could qualify for one considering what I have been learning about both our fellow human beings and the fucked up nature of this world increasingly for the past many years…

]]>
By: Shaikh https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-40365 Sun, 13 Apr 2025 20:43:28 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-40365 I wonder what makes Christians so obsessed with the end times..Jews and Muslims also have an eschatological culture but never have I seen anywhere near this obsession and constant debating among any of these two communities regarding the ends of times like I have seen it in Christendom.

]]>
By: Shaikh https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-40364 Sun, 13 Apr 2025 20:41:16 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-40364 Finally got a chance of finishing this article of yours..

/Literature majors might be squinting their eyes at this point./

Dude I have never been one and this got me squinting my eyes lol.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39511 Mon, 18 Nov 2024 16:04:56 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39511 In reply to Jen Smith.

You’d have to scour the scrolls and their modern commentaries for specific instances of specific passages being read in specific ways (likewise other apocrypha, like Jubilees or Enoch and ancient apocalyptic literature generally). But the general conclusion of experts is yes: this is exactly what they were doing. And it is obviously what Christian authors were doing, as proved by Preston’s own evidence (Revelation and 2 Peter are doing exactly this, as he documents; he just rejects a sound understanding of what they are doing, because he ignores the context in which they were doing it, and their own literary cues).

]]>
By: Jen Smith https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39506 Sat, 16 Nov 2024 18:10:11 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39506 This is great work, thank you. Do you also believe that the original non-literal, prophetic language of destruction (e.g., Isaiah 13:10) was transformed into literal descriptions of future cosmic events of destruction in apocalyptic thought (Dead Sea Scrolls, other apocalyptic works, NT)? Are there examples of this happening in the DSS or other early apocalypses?

This seems plausible to me because we do see for example non-prophetic texts in the Hebrew Bible are reinterpreted as prophetic proofs of Jesus through creative pesher techniques, so similarly I could see the language of judgement going from non-literal to more literal.

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39451 Fri, 08 Nov 2024 15:15:11 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39451 In reply to John Miqueli.

My article here. It explains the point and the evidence for it.

But if you mean on trickster narratives generally see the corresponding section of Archetypes and Motifs in Folklore and Literature.

While on the Genesis Serpent as an instantiation of that archetype see “Devil, Trickster and Fool” in Mythlore 17 (1991) by Tim Callahan and “The Trickster as Personification of Primordial Chaos” in Anthropos 118 (2023) by Deon Liebenberg. There is also a very useful bibliography on the Eden story as trickster narrative in Daniel Sarlo’s conference paper “Deception and Trickery in the Book of Genesis”.

]]>
By: John Miqueli https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39441 Thu, 07 Nov 2024 19:08:09 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39441 In reply to Richard Carrier.

It’s now clear to me how Dan McClellan and Chris Lee are mis-analyzing the text. Thank you for the clarification.

Where can I point Dan McClellan to regarding said trickster narrative of the serpent playing on the ambiguity of a death penalty vs immediate execution?

]]>
By: Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39419 Wed, 06 Nov 2024 14:16:49 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39419 In reply to John Miqueli.

The phrase is “die to die,” imperfect + infinitive (same verb, repeated twice, once in each case). The question is: what does that weird phrase mean. The answer is in Genesis 20, the LXX, Sirach, and the Life of Adam and Eve.

Lee’s case is refuted by mine. And I am using Lee’s own data. Lee is an apologist with an agenda. So you have to see what Lee’s argument is and compare it to mine. That’s why you have to address my case, not just “cite Lee.”

You would know this if you read Lee.

What Lee targets as the “apologetical” reading that they want to make go away is the “spiritual death” interpretation, which neither I nor Lee believe credible, and the “immortality lost” interpretation (that there was a change in the laws of physics), which is fundamentalist (the main position Lee is against—not themselves being a fundamentaist—and which I also agree with Lee is probably false).

Focused on those targets, Lee ignores all the evidence I present that it means a sentence and not an execution and thus has nothing to do with what concerns Lee at all—it is not the apologetical position Lee argues against. And what Lee argues for is a different apologetical position: that Adam and Eve were never immortal to begin with. Which I think is true (they lived forever because of access to the tree of life), but Lee has confused that position with the immediate-execution position and so bites that bullet and implies God meant immediate but chose leniency (a commuted sentence) instead of killing them right away; Lee does not consider the evidence or argument for my position (they simply dismiss the conclusion as unavailable), yet their position (on Adam and Eve always being, technically, mortal) is not only congruent with my position, my position, Lee admits, is that of every ancient interpretation of this text that exists (p. 226).

Indeed Lee’s own case makes this an exile-to-death case just like the examples I give. Lee wants that to be a late interpretation. But none of their evidence establishes that, and mine (e.g. Gen. 20, Proverbs) establishes the contrary. Lee has simply mis-analyzed the text in terms of folklore theory, never recognizing the story as a trickster narrative with clear cues as to its meaning (Lee expects myths and folklore to explicitly state their intentions; no mythologist or folklorist thinks myths and folklore explicitly state their intentions). So Lee is simply wrong. The evidence supports me. Even Lee’s own evidence. There is no actual evidence supporting Lee.

That’s why, to dismiss my case, you can’t cite Lee. Rather, you need to find something in Lee that (a) actually answers my case (and not someone else’s) and (b) is not fallacious.

So, let’s see that.

]]>
By: John Miqueli https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/31318#comment-39403 Tue, 05 Nov 2024 17:08:45 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=31318#comment-39403 In reply to Richard Carrier.

To clarify, you, Dan McClellan, and Chris Lee say the first “to die” in Genesis 2:17 is in the infinitive absolute. Dan McClellan and Chris Lee say the second “to die” is in the finite form while you say it is in the simple imperfect

Sorry I only have time to refer to Dan McClellan’s YouTube shorts on Genesis 2:17 and Chris Lee’s dissertation above that explain why this paronomastic infinitive means that Adam would physically die that day

Above you say, “Chris Lee summarizes the data but comes to apologetical conclusions.” Chris Lee concludes Genesis 2:17 means that Adam would physically die that day while apologetical conclusions say it means that Adam would not physically die that day

Thank you

]]>