Comments for Richard Carrier Blogs https://www.richardcarrier.info/ Announcing appearances, publications, and analysis of questions historical, philosophical, and political by author, philosopher, and historian Richard Carrier. Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:19:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 Comment on Comparing Apologetical Methods: Jonathan Sheffield vs. Michael Licona by Islam Hassan https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/38758#comment-46090 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:19:00 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=38758#comment-46090 In reply to Richard Carrier.

Yes, I meant that he admits to a lot more than the apologists realize.

I totally understand what you mean about him pushing an overt possibiliter fallacy in his conclusions.

Btw Dr. Carrier, have you ever directly reviewed or engaged the aforementioned Gathercole paper?
I know it didn’t move the field’s consensus at all, but it gets cited a lot directly and indirectly by Christians in debates and discussions about the gospels.

]]>
Comment on Comparing Apologetical Methods: Jonathan Sheffield vs. Michael Licona by Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/38758#comment-46087 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:41:49 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=38758#comment-46087 In reply to Islam Hassan.

You might mean that Gathercole admits to a lot more in that paper than apologists citing it seem to realize (as apologists rarely read the things they cite or claim to have read) and pushes instead an overt possibiliter fallacy instead (well, maybe x; therefore, you get to believe x).

But that’s still not the honesty we get from Sheffield. Because Gathercole uses those fallacies to make false claims, exactly as stated in its abstract (which he will have written, so he is doing this on purpose):

Practical considerations make the presence of author’s names very likely. Second-century Christian literature is replete with references to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John as authors of Gospels, and there is never any sense that the Gospels were anonymous or written by others. The most likely conclusion to be drawn is that the attributions of authorship are original.

Every statement above that I put in bold is a lie insofar as it does not follow from his presentation of the evidence, even as-is but more so when (as usually happens with apologetics) we put back in what he left out (e.g. all the evidence that no one knew they had names as of the publication of Marcion’s canon; the unreliability and even absurdity of the claims of Papias; the significance of the kata designation across them all; as well as the absence of any earlier discussions—since Gathercole is unjustifiedly adopting the apologetical consensus that Papias is pre-Marcion). This is deliberate deception in aid of propaganda, disguised under a veneer of “detailed scholarship” and “moderate tone” and “academic elite discourse style.”

This is not the sort of thing Sheffield would write. He advances a similar argument to similar claims, but admits to its defects and faces them, and rather than pushing a fake “well, duh” argument he goes right to the real heart of the matter and oversells the reliability of Christian preservers and reporters. So his approach is honest and transparent: he makes clear that, yes, he is simply counting on the reliability of Christian preservers and reporters, and making the best honest case he can for that. Gathercole, by contrast, tries to hide that as being what he is doing by making sham claims about the actual state of the evidence and background.

Gathercole is coming at you sideways. Sheffield is coming at you straight.

]]>
Comment on The Sleeping Terror: 1 Peter Might Be Authentic … and Thereby Prove Jesus Did Not Exist! (Part 2: Consequences) by Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/44841#comment-46086 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:14:45 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=44841#comment-46086 In reply to Matt.

Oh funny! You posted this the moment I just posted my reply, which catches your point.

]]>
Comment on The Sleeping Terror: 1 Peter Might Be Authentic … and Thereby Prove Jesus Did Not Exist! (Part 2: Consequences) by Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/44841#comment-46085 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:12:34 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=44841#comment-46085 In reply to Matt.

The burden is on them. That’s the significance of the resulting prior being low.

But you might be confusing two different things.

First, that Jesus was heavily mythologized in the Gospels entails a ~ 1 in 4 chance he was historical. So to believe he is historical entails a burden of over 4 to 1 on the historicist: they need evidence that is collectively over four times more likely on historicity; they cannot prevail with just “evidence,” but need that much (in scale and quality) to turn things around.

Here though I misunderstood your original question. You mean by “mythologized” simply “deified,” believing someone is now a superpower in heaven you can pray to and get things from (like being saved). That is actually so widely documented as usually happening immediately, it gives no prior against historicity at all. In fact the idea of instantly deifying kings and emperors (complete with effective prayers, priesthoods, the whole shebang) was so standard around them that the Christians simply adapted that apparatus for Jesus (making Christianity entirely a product of its time). The same happened for Hadrian’s lover Antinoos, for famed athletes (their newly supplied corpse parts became pilgrimage and prayer targets within months of their death), and so on.

Indeed that’s the point of studies like The Son of God in the Roman World and Paul and Imperial Divine Honors.

So if by “mythologization” you actually mean only “deification,” that almost certainly happened mere days after Jesus died; and that would be normal for historical persons then. So 1 Peter does not evince Jesus didn’t exist merely because it shows he was rapidly deified. Rapid deification was routine. It’s elaborate mythologization that is not (the spinning of wild fantasies about their journeys on Earth).

]]>
Comment on The Sleeping Terror: 1 Peter Might Be Authentic … and Thereby Prove Jesus Did Not Exist! (Part 2: Consequences) by Matt https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/44841#comment-46084 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:10:28 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=44841#comment-46084 In reply to Richard Carrier.

It didn’t occur to me when I was writing earlier comments but a possible counter example that is also contemporary is the phenomenon of emperor deification. My argument might not be as strong as I thought, although there are differences of course between what would have happened to a historic Jesus and the emperor, and arguably the degree was greater with Jesus.

]]>
Comment on Comparing Apologetical Methods: Jonathan Sheffield vs. Michael Licona by Islam Hassan https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/38758#comment-46083 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 09:58:08 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=38758#comment-46083 In reply to Richard Carrier.

My comment was very vague. I didn’t mean Gathercole’s general attitude in his apologetics, I meant his approach in arguing against the anonymity of the gospels in the paper “The Alleged Anonymity of the Canonical Gospels” (Journal of Theological Studies, 2018).

]]>
Comment on The Sleeping Terror: 1 Peter Might Be Authentic … and Thereby Prove Jesus Did Not Exist! (Part 2: Consequences) by Matt https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/44841#comment-46082 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 03:19:10 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=44841#comment-46082 In reply to Richard Carrier.

I don’t see why the burden of proof isn’t on historicity defenders to show that it’s normal or plausible that a normal human can get mythologized this quickly (20 years at most, if not 10 if 1 Peter is from the early 40s) and to this degree instead of on mythicists to show that a savior deity can get humanized in 40-45 years after inception, which there are multiple examples of exactly in the time period the gospels were written in. Both sound improbable to the layman but one should sound more improbable than the other. They really should be the ones writing books and articles on how that can happen instead of you and other mythicists.

]]>
Comment on Was Jesus-Is-Michael an Early Christian Mystery Teaching? by Matt https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/18485#comment-46081 Thu, 19 Nov 2026 03:07:23 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=18485#comment-46081 In reply to Richard Carrier.

Thanks for the replies here and the newer article.

]]>
Comment on AI Is Garbage and a Bubble (Please Learn This) by Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/38652#comment-46080 Wed, 18 Nov 2026 18:38:25 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=38652#comment-46080 In reply to Pascal Bercker.

More delusion or propaganda by simply ignoring what my actual position is and falsely describing it as something else.

Why you think this works on anyone here escapes me.

]]>
Comment on AI Is Garbage and a Bubble (Please Learn This) by Richard Carrier https://www.richardcarrier.info/archives/38652#comment-46079 Wed, 18 Nov 2026 18:37:29 +0000 https://www.richardcarrier.info/?p=38652#comment-46079 In reply to Pascal Bercker.

You have never correctly described my position.

Even after I have explained it to you multiple different ways.

I can only conclude you are delusional. Or a disinformation propagandist.

]]>