If you want to shop Christmas gifts for your loved ones on Amazon and force Amazon to pay me a commission on all of it (which is kind of like taxing the rich!), now is the time. Because Black Friday deals are on, from now through Monday. Whether you buy any of the following or not doesn’t matter. Just click through their links anyway and start shop-searching. If you check out within 24 hours, Amazon will cut me a percentage on everything in your cart no matter what it is (except for kindle sales, and things by third-party sellers, which I don’t get a commission on). But I will be recommending some stuff for you.

This is also true for Amazons in other countries. The book links below should get you started by converting to the country’s Amazon you are in; but the product links in the next sentence probably won’t. Nevertheless, in the US you can start by buying anything you want me to get a commission on, whether it’s a Lord of the Rings Elven Warrior Sword or a $10,000 Bee Goddess diamond sword necklace. Or just buy Legend of Zelda for Nintendo. Or a box of rocks. All great gifts for the elves, geologists, and Nintendo players in your life.

But today I want to recommend three more books in my specialty field of ancient science: The Lagoon: How Aristotle Invented Science by Armand Marie Leroi; Technology and Culture in Greek and Roman Antiquity by Serafino Cuomo; and The Renaissance of Mechanics: Ancient Science in the Age of Humanism by Walter Roy Laird. These are not the books you would expect. I’ve covered textbook histories of ancient science already. But these are the messy human story that is often glossed over or overlooked.

Only one of these features in my dissertation, because the others were published after. But they all do one thing well: show you with specific and real examples the personal reality of the mindset required for inventing science—and getting it back after Christianity killed it. These authors do not discuss Christianity, they focus solely on the mindset required. But when you contrast their accounts with the fantasy of pseudohistory Christians promote for why science “needed” them, it becomes very clear why that story is baloney—and how this story is the real one.

I’ll be brief today describing the merits and content of each book…


Armand Leroi’s The Lagoon: How Aristotle Invented Science is the best popular discussion of the side of Aristotle most amateurs forget (or weren’t even told about): Aristotle gets knocked for his sloppy physics, but he wasn’t a physicist. He was a biologist. And it is in that field that he did some of the most incredible work, and it is through that field that he invented the modern conception of science itself. This is important because the pop lore is that Aristotle invented science through his shaky physics and metaphysics, when in fact that was all an afterthought, a tour he had to round out to complete his lecture series on the natural world for his students. Aristotle’s biological works are his most scientific—often actual scientific studies and not just lectures. As the book’s description says, he “wrote vast treatises on animals, dissecting them, classifying them, recording how they lived, fed, and bred. He founded a science. It can even be said that he founded science itself.” And the origins of modern science can’t really be understood without that.

Armand Leroi is a biologist himself, so he comes at all of this from a fully informed perspective. He often relates what Aristotle said to his own experiences as a biologist today. Although not being a historian could hamper him, I didn’t notice anything outrageously wrong on my review of the text, and his citations and bibliography are admirably good. Maybe there are mistakes I missed. And he is also not shy about expressing his opinions, but as a competent writer, a competent reader can tell when they are getting his opinion on something, and when getting facts. The book is very readable and will suck you in, as it relates the story of Plato’s anti-empiricism and Aristotle’s rebellion against it, all the way to talking to fishermen, huntsmen, beekeepers, tillers, and wading in local geography to hunt and study life. All leading to real science.

Leroi’s book includes Aristotle’s errors and biases, but as well his remarkable achievements, and what is remarkable about them. His overall story makes clear what kind of mindset is required to invent and advance science in the first place, through the example of Aristotle doing just that. Many good books explore the life and mind of Darwin. This very much feels similar in its focus and approach. I highly recommend The Lagoon for all readers who want to understand the world better, and better understand our world now.


Serafino Cuomo’s Technology and Culture in Greek and Roman Antiquity was so useful to my dissertation that I cited it ten times in The Scientist in the Early Roman Empire, on everything from the ancient understanding and definition of natural cause vs. intelligent design to lists of “engineers who may have written scientific books prior to the Roman era.” I cite her for discussions of Apollodorus (an important Roman-era engineer often now forgotten); for the overlap of culture and science (like the “belief that new diseases were caused by immoral living”); and for challenging popular mythologies today: like that the ancients did not advance the science of ballistics (Cuomo understands the difference between their not having it and our not having it), or didn’t believe in progress (she analyzes remarks by the engineer Philo of Byzantium against that point), or abhorred altering or improving on nature (Cuomo “provides considerable evidence that many Romans were proud of altering nature for their convenience,” even linking their pride in “nature-altering projects” to their national “self-image”). She also dispels the myth that they did not believe in getting their hands dirty or consulting with the working class: Cuomo is among the scholars I list as having “argued against any sort of split between scientists and craftsmen, or between learning and handiwork,” and who includes “discussion of the social status of artisans and the values unique to their class” and the overlap this had with known scientists. Cuomo’s study places ancient scientists in their cultural context, which aids in understanding the mindset that made and drove them—and thus made and drove what became modern science.

I had only one criticism there, that on ancient artillery “she overdraws some conclusions and might err in some basic physics” but even then I note her treatment remains “worthwhile.” As just one example of the kind of thing to look for, Cuomo mistakes projectile range and impact-force as variables that can be adjusted independently in design (54) when in terms of physics they are inseparable: once a projectile leaves its launch, it only has one momentum, velocity times mass—yes, diminished over distance by friction with the air, but somewhat also recovered as gravity adds energy on the downside of its parabola. Especially (but not only) when using parabolic (indirect) artillery fire, there is no way to extend range and much change how hard the projectile hits. It’s the same energy imparted either way. And longer range requires more energy. So if you can double the distance a projectile flies, you’ll be near doubling its force of impact by default, relative to another weapon. The catapult has no further effect once the shot is away. So its design can make no difference here. Yes, a catapult can deliver a lot more force to a target at point blank, but any weapon can be aimed short, while the loss of energy to longer range fire will always be the same. But this is a nitpick. The distinction I am making has no real effect on her account. So, too, anything else you might quibble with. Her treatment is otherwise excellent, especially as it concerns more the cultural history of the R&D and its political effects than the physics of ballistic warfare.

Besides a valuable Introduction and Epilogue, this volume covers five distinct subjects in corresponding chapters: 1. The definition of technê in classical Athens (“art” or “craft” or “design,” as distinct from nature and the natural, and therefore, scientific and philosophical naturalism); 2. The Hellenistic military revolution (building out the underappreciated importance of the torsion catapult as both an engineering triumph and catalyst for the idea of funding scientific research in antiquity, just as modern military industry drives a lot of research science investment now); 3. Death and the craftsman (studying the lives, values, tools, and knowledge of ancient engineers through their often elaborate epitaphs); 4. Boundary disputes in the Roman Empire (covering what we can learn about Roman Imperial technical knowledge from land surveying disputes, and the important rise of technical knowledge as a hallmark of authority); and 5. Architects of late antiquity (using parallel stories of engineers and their shifting social status to answer the question “what happened to technical knowledge as the empire went from the second to the sixth century?” which informs part of the complex story of the then-decline of Western civilization).

These are all tied together in the first and last chapters. And what you will take away from all of this is a sense of the intersection of culture, technology, and science in the pagan world—and their mutual causal importance (only chapter five delves into the integration of inherited knowledge in later Christian culture). Cuomo is an outstanding author and historian of ancient mathematics (all her works are invaluable) and she brings that perspective in all five chapters here. So I recommend Technology and Culture for any audience.


Walter Laird’s The Renaissance of Mechanics: Ancient Science in the Age of Humanism tells a longer and more technical story: how, essentially, modern physics (in the specific form of mechanics) was invented by pagans, and abandoned by Christians, and then what it took to get it back a thousand years later. It is an essential read for historians owing to its thoroughness of detail. Yes, the absurd price of this one exemplifies the robber-baron status of greedy corporate academic publishing now. It’s gross. I can’t solve the moral crisis of late-stage capitalism, alas. And I’ll only get tipped about three bucks if you buy it through the link here, though the author should get twelve or more (I don’t earn on kindle or used book sales; and Laird gets only a cut of kindle sales). So, no worries if you try borrowing it through interlibrary loan instead. I couldn’t even afford it myself. I had to briefly borrow and skim one (but owning a copy is on my wishlist).

As the title hints, only about a third of this book is on antiquity, but it’s a pretty good survey, one of the best on the single subject of mechanics, including a lot of stuff you might not have known about. The other two thirds cover the loss of this information in the middle ages (when the trend today is to disingenuously deny anything was lost at all) and then its recovery in the early and late Renaissance (with some discussion of the role of the Arabs as one of the intermediaries). But it does tie this all together. For example, Laird links all three parts of the book together when documenting how Galileo rediscovered lost passages and findings of Hero of Alexandria, transforming his entire study of physics. So antiquity plays an important narrative role across the entire book, even as its chronological lens moves through its loss in the Middle Ages to its recovery in the early and late Renaissance.

Readers should know this book is academic and detailed, not written for a popular audience. And I wasn’t able to vet it all so I can’t say it’s always right about everything. But I can vouch for the fact that there is no better one-volume treatment of its subject to be had. If you want a high-level deep dive into a crucial aspect of the story of how we got modern science from the pagan mind, and this time from a physics perspective, The Renaissance of Mechanics is the book to read.

§

All comments go to moderation except for Patrons etc. See Comments & Moderation Policy.

Share this:

Discover more from Richard Carrier Blogs

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.