I have often noted or even used good ideas from amateur scholars like David Oliver Smith and R.G. Price (not to be confused with Robert M. Price). I even named Price in my original study of the historicity of Jesus as among the few amateurs doing work worthy of attention, even if it didn’t always persuade (Historicity 53–54); and in my latest study I listed Smith’s study of the use of the Epistles in the Gospels and Acts as among the required reading on that subject (Paradigm 34n36), because it is that good. But Price so far as I know only has a B.S. in biology. Smith has a J.D., which is a doctorate in jurisprudence, a top level research degree in law, which is closer to a relevant skillset. And I get the impression Smith is much more facile with ancient Greek than Price.
I usually caution against relying on amateurs (see my remarks in A Primer on Actually Doing Your Own Research) and often their work goes very badly (see my examples in The Problem with Varieties of Jesus Mythicism); but I also think experts can evaluate their merits for you, so you know which ones you can trust more, or which of their results you can (see my examples in Three Genuinely Good Lay Treatments of Bible History). But even then, you should always double check even experts, much more amateurs, before trusting their results (see my remarks in A Vital Primer on Media Literacy and, for example, How to Evaluate Expert Testimony and Things Fall Apart Only When You Check). Peer review kind of serves to perform this function for you (see On Evaluating Arguments from Consensus). But that has been breaking down lately (see Exposing T.C. Schmidt’s Oxford Apologetics and The Korean “Comfort Women” Dust-Up and the Function of Peer Review in History along with these linked resources). So you increasingly need outside review to trust things.
I don’t have time or even a good reason to review every amateur work, even of those who sometimes do good work. It is costly labor for me to do that, so I would need to be paid for it. I can only afford to eat that cost myself when (1) they have done a bit of research that looks good at a glance, on a question that (2) directly informs something I am already working on. I recently wrote up an example of this from Smith: The Mystery of the Seven Loaves as Mythographic Composition in Mark. But today I am compelled to look at bad examples, one from Smith and one from Price. Because understanding why they are bad will help you apply general principles to evaluating any work yourself, expert or amateur (and, hopefully, help you avoid making the same kinds of mistakes in your own reasoning).
The Main Methodological Point
All mistakes (and, as it happens, all lies and crankery and apologetics and propaganda as well) usually function by misusing a method that resembles one that actually works. Consider the way cranks will call every criticism ad hominem because that is a real fallacy and thus a real rebuttal when it’s true—so they want to trade on the respectability and emotional persuasiveness of that real complaint even when it does not in fact describe anything they happen to be talking about. “Criticized what we said” and “criticized us” become conflated in their mind (or they want them to become conflated in your mind) in order to distract from what actually happened, all to avoid the consequences—of, for example, being caught making a mistake and correctly called out for it, and from the mistake being then correctly explained by a lack of expertise, carefulness, honesty, or whichever thing can be documented as most likely having caused it, thus giving reason to not implicitly trust more from them without checking first. “How dare you insult me” is the way you cover up the actual “how dare you catch me” that happened. And the best way to do that is to steal the valor of a real example of the thing you wish happened and misapply it to what actually happened..
Price and Smith aren’t cranks or liars. They are, rather, just over-enthusiastically self-persuaded by bad arguments from time to time. And that does have some to do with a lack of professional training and its concomitant experience. To illustrate this I won’t be reviewing either entire book that I will be taking examples from today. I am not actually interested in them because they seem too flawed to be worth more time, or else address subjects I don’t have enough interest in to carve time out for. Nor will I be addressing every single argument they make even on the single example I will be using. I will only cover enough to make the point. The rest of their arguments could be just as bad, or they could even be good but nevertheless inadequate to carry their point given the mistakes I do call out.
Tomorrow I will add my discussion of Smith and give you my Conclusion regarding both.
R.G. Price and Building on vs. Drowning in Epicycles
My example from Price is from Cracking the New Testament (2026), chapter five, where he argues for a particular hidden meaning intended by the Parable of the Sower. As per my general point, he is here borrowing a real method: Mark absolutely intended hidden meanings in his stories and parables, so we absolutely need to try to reverse engineer what they are, and that involves using techniques similar to ones Price does employ. Because not only do we have many secure examples establishing Mark is doing this (the expert literature is rife with examples: Historicity §10.4), but Mark himself outright says so—more than once, including in the middle of the very Parable of the Sower story Price examines, which is indeed wrapped around this point, thus signaling it’s importance; and again in the Seven Loaves case from Smith and Farrer that I explored before.
The Parable of the Sower is one of the few parables Jesus actually explains the secret of (Mark 4:1-20). But what Mark has him explain in secret to his apostles is that it is a generic moral lesson about “kinds” of people, not specific characters in the story. Missionaries are sowing seeds of the gospel, and some seed falls on the road (the ὁδόν as signifying the Christian mission is a gospel theme across Mark: Historicity 419–21) and takes no root because Satan snatches it away from their minds, and some falls on rocky ground and gladly takes root but so shallowly that it withers as soon as pressure comes, and some falls on thorny ground where it is choked away by the desires of life, and some falls on good ground and thus bears a crop, “some thirty, some sixty, some a hundred times what was sown.”
Which is a truism. The missionary reading this is being told, “look, get ready, some of your marks will ignore your pitch, some will love it but leave as soon as it gets hard, and others will get distracted by life and fall away, but some will get it, and will themselves spread the message, and win even more converts.” It’s a shoulder-to-the-boulder morale boosting fable. Every pyramid scheme has some similar pep talk. And couching it into an ooo-aah parable form makes it sound wise and ingenious, when really it’s kind of a lame point, like explaining why chairs have legs, or that some people will always vote for Nader. The film Circle of Iron (whose script was originally written by Bruce Lee) made fun of this kind of thing with the mocking line “and horses don’t have udders, cows can’t whinny, up is down, and sideways is straight ahead!”
So it’s reasonable to wonder if Mark meant something even more hidden by this otherwise dumb point. Price wants to argue that the four kinds of people are represented by four specific characters in the Gospel: John the Baptist, Simon Peter, James Zebedee, and Paul. That’s plausible because Mark is covertly selling Paul throughout and even has Jesus doing it elsewhere. So it would make sense if he was here too. Unfortunately there is no methodologically sound way to get beyond just “strong believers” all the way to “Paul specifically” or even anything distinctive about Paul’s mission—other than that it was materially more successful because he was selling a cheaper product to a larger audience.
But the thing is, possibly does not get you probably. And just one coincidence can’t get you there either, because of the multiple comparisons fallacy: if any link counts, the chance of there being a link by chance approaches 100% and thus cannot signal intent. You need the coincidence to be improbable in order to signal intent. And the probability being measured is the total probability, not the incident probability. For example, the probability you will win the lottery is incident; the probability someone will win the lottery is total. And so we want to know the total probability we’d find anything that connects, not the probability that the one thing we find would be it. And that’s not because Mark can’t have had the intent you allege. It’s because we cannot claim to know he did on evidence that is as likely to be there on any other reason.
- Intent is only more probable than not when intended parallels are substantially more likely than a coincidence.
So what we need is more than one link. And we cannot create links by adding explanatory epicycles (extra leaps of logic to convert a non-link into a link), because that costs us more in probability than we gain by it (that’s The Cost of Making Excuses). And yet, again per my general point, it is easy to mistake doing this for a legitimate method. In some cases, a single epicycle can recover its cost in gained explanatory power—but (a) it has to actually do that (so this being sometimes the case does not justify always adding one epicycle and concluding you’ve succeeded at explaining something) and (b) it can rarely be more than one (because there is usually no way to recover the resulting geometric progression of cost, e.g. two epicycles that are 10% unlikely is 1% unlikely, which is ten times less likely).
Amateurs will “skip over” these caveats and just mistake epicycling as a correct method. It’s not. I show why mathematically, and what it takes to overcome that, in my discussion of interpolations. Amateurs will also mistake backgrounding as epicycling, because they look similar. Backgrounding is when you have what looks like an epicycle but, lo and behold, you can present independent evidence the epicycle exists. And it must be independent evidence. That it rescues your theory is not independent evidence it’s true. You need something that does not require your theory to be true. Chapters four and five of Historicity detail nothing but background data that can “epicycle” theories without cost, because that background is all established by its own evidence as true (or true as stated), and as true regardless of the theory tested (whether Jesus existed or not).
To show you what I mean, consider that Mark’s Jesus says the converts who really let the gospel take root won’t fall away—and will even convert more people to the cause, by sometimes thirtyfold, sometimes sixtyfold, sometimes a hundredfold. This is traditionally interpreted as meaning increasing degrees of enthusiasm will produce increasing degrees of outcome. But why specifically those numbers? I noted before that numerology is big with these authors. Do the numbers mean something? Experts have so far only tracked one, and it’s informative: Mark is alluding here to Genesis 26:12, “Isaac planted crops” in what would one day be the holy “land and the same year reaped a hundredfold, because the Lord blessed him.” Isaac is of course the human sacrifice Jesus was resubstituted for to replace the Yom Kippur (Historicity, Elements 18 & 43). Mark is thus midrashing on Genesis 26:12. When you do what god blesses, you will profit a hundredfold, representing the greatest possible outcome.
Isaac sowed literal seed for a hundredfold material wealth, staking his claim on a literal future kingdom; Jesus (and thus the future missionaries embodying him) will sow figurative seed for a hundredfold spiritual wealth, staking their claim on a spiritual future kingdom. That’s very likely the intended sense. There are then the smaller numbers. Yet the numbers sixty and thirty appear all over the OT but never in any context applicable, in the way Genesis 26 is. Only one supported step of logic is needed for that verse: the conversion of literal material things into figurative or spiritual things, which is so standardly done across Mark it isn’t improbable to assume this intent is shared again here, and the context even evinces it is here (literal sowing and its spiritual sense are demonstrably present—we do not have to presume them). But that means we can’t pull any other verse in, even if we can invent more steps of logic to convert them into an applicable sense, because those extra steps are unsupported and thus improbable, pushing us in the opposite direction. Disregarding the mathematical cost in probability of “just so” stories that make things fit the evidence is a common amateur mistake. So we just don’t know why Mark wrote thirty and sixty, other than that he needed some numbers to signify different degrees of enthusiasm short of full.
Still, this shows that sometimes we can find biblical sources for numbers that happen to match our context with an apposite meaning too improbable by chance. But sometimes the source they play on is outside the Bible. In the two swords pericope in Luke we just got lucky and have that extrabiblical source; but a lot of the time we can’t expect to have been so lucky, and thus the meaning we could have extracted is lost to us forever. And that’s just that. And here, so far, I have never seen anyone make a good case for these numbers meaning anything in particular. Price doesn’t even try. Instead, he ignores the numbers, and notices instead that the second group relates to “rocky ground” which puns with Simon’s nickname “Rocky” (Peter). And indeed, as this would predict, Peter is the one who is enthusiastic until threatened and then he abandons the gospel. So Price is on good ground here (pun intended). Because we have more than one coincidence here: rock and rocky; and what happens in the story to the one so designated.
But then things get weird. Not following any criteria of allusion (as developed by Brodie & McDonald and validated in Proving History at the end of chapter five), Price wants the seed on the road that Satan snatches away to refer to John the Baptist. But he can only make that happen by completely changing the evidence we have: he wants there to have been a lost original version of Mark (for which there is no evidence) that actually had John the Baptist the one who went into the wilderness to be tempted by Satan instead of Jesus (a weird change nowhere else in evidence). Price does the same with James, whom he needs to be the thorn-choked one, completely rewriting the evidence to have this unevidenced proto-Mark say he is the one who betrays Jesus for money instead of Judas (another weird change nowhere else in evidence, and not even plausible given how this role has to be performed by a Judah and not a Jacob).
That’s not even a complete list of the stack of improbable things Price needs to get his theory. And even after all that there really is no concrete link with the “good soil” and Paul. Nothing connects to Paul uniquely or his mission to the Gentiles—no more than to just any deep-rooted receiver of the gospel. Which is unlike the Seven Loaves story which connects with the Gentile mission repeatedly and conspicuously, and contrasts with the Jewish mission almost explicitly by an otherwise-improbable stack of coincidences. The evidence is there and stacks. Nothing the like is here.
Since Price has none of that, he replaces it with two unevidenced rewrites of the evidence, and a fuzzy leap of logic of comparison to Paul (among much else, but let’s pretend he only needed these three). If you have to believe in three radical new theories to believe in a fourth, you’re going in the wrong direction methodologically. Probability just goes down and down here, not up and up. Because of the conjunction fallacy, the probability that Price’s theory is correct must be less than the probability of any (and in fact all) of his other wild theories. So, for example, if the probability that Mark has been edited to replace James as betrayer with Judas is 10%, then Price’s theory has to be less than 10% likely. If the probability that Mark has also been edited to replace John encountering the devil with Jesus is also 10%, the combined probability of both is 1%, and Price’s theory of the Parable of the Sower must be less than 1% likely. And so on. It well approaches zero by the time you get through his stack.
Theories can only be known to be probable when you are working from the evidence there actually is. If you have to radically change all the evidence to get your theory to be likely, your theory is not likely. You are in fact staring at evidence against your theory. The only exception is when you have really, really good evidence for your change. For example, the odds against interpolation explaining 1 Thessalonians 2:14–16 are hundreds to one. But it just so happens that we have a stack of evidence for it being interpolated (other than its conflict with a theory it threatens) that is at least thousands to one more likely, thus overwhelming its low prior. Price has no such quantity or quality of evidence here. Not even for one of his leaps, much less all of them. His method is wrong. It does not generate knowledge. It only satisfies cognitive elation, a common driver of false beliefs, especially religions and conspiracy theories.
To understand the difference, consider that a case could be made that the middle two examples do track almost as Price wants. Peter is indeed symbolic of the stony people, and James and John (together) are symbolic of the thorny people. Not (as Price thought) because they betray Jesus for money, but because of their fight for future glory that Jesus chastises, and their replacement with two criminals with Jesus at the crucifixion. That represents the corresponding message and story arc—just as Simon Peter is replaced by Simon of Cyrene (as I explain in Historicity, 444–51). The middle two categories thus track to the story Mark tells. But the outer two categories seem to reflect everyone else, not particular characters—it just means all the people who ignore the gospel and all the people who deeply embrace it and carry the mission forward. There is no character exemplifying these who connects in more than one way with what appears here.
For an example of the same kind of design intended in Luke, see indeed the Two Swords Pericope, especially as I expand on from the literature in Paradigm (189–209; the following table is on 198), where the same technique appears: two of the lemmas refer to named characters (this time, Peter and Judas), while the other two are generically directed (even the lemma that encompasses James and John, a shared commonality with Mark’s Sower Parable). The resulting structure looks like this:

The evidence for all this is extensive, a stack of improbable coincidences, not just one (all detailed in Paradigm); and it all follows from the evidence as it is, no epicycles needed. We don’t have to invent or change any of the evidence to get that result. Unlike Price, who does.
By contrast, consider Price’s attempt to get John to be the one who ventures into the wilderness with Satan. Even apart from the fact that that story never says he fails the temptation, so the story never matches the narrative of Satan snatching away their interest in the gospel, the grammar of Mark’s entire pericope is too consistent and elegant to ever have meant this to be anyone other than Jesus. It’s also theologically apt: Jesus reverses Satan’s rebellion (Philippians 2, Historicity, 534, 184), just as he reverses Israel’s submission to the Satanic temptations Jesus resists (as Matthew understood Mark’s 40-day symbolism to represent: Historicity, 468–69); and Jesus has to be the one who defeats a Great Adversary before coming into his kingdom, as that is a component of the Rank-Raglan hero Mark is conforming Jesus to (Historicity, 233).
But…
- You must attend to how ancient authors were taught to compose.
So your theory needs to make sense of the Greek, not of some English translation of it. Hence more telling is the language, which Price misses (not being as versatile in Greek I presume):
At that time Jesus came from Nazareth in Galilee and was baptized by John in the Jordan. Just as Jesus was coming up out of the water, he saw heaven being torn open and the Spirit descending on him like a dove. And a voice came from heaven: “You are my Son, whom I love; with you I am well pleased.” At once the Spirit sent him out into the wilderness, and he was in the wilderness forty days, being tempted by Satan. He was with the wild animals, and angels attended him.
The pronoun “him” is in the Greek, as a masculine accusative, and must take the most recent subject or object noun, and that’s Jesus, not John. John is never even a subject or object. When last mentioned he is an indirect object (Jesus is baptized “by John” just as he gets then tempted “by Satan” which is itself a parallel construction proving Jesus is meant to be the movant in both stories). So John cannot grammatically be the referent of a following pronoun. Indeed, you might say the Spirit is the last noun mentioned (or even the Voice, but as that is feminine, it can’t be the referent of a masculine pronoun). But Mark (unlike Price) knows how to compose: to avoid that confusion he has made the Spirit the subject of the next sentence, thus excluding it from also being its object.
Which actually proves the entire intent of this pericope is that Jesus is the one being baptized then tempted: because the parallel construction is “the Spirit descended on him” and then “the Spirit drove him out” into the wilderness. The Spirit is the agent: it moves into Jesus, and thus obviously then moves Jesus—not John, in whom the Spirit did not enter. Indeed, Mark then has the Spirit reverse its direction and “go out” of Jesus at his death: for ἐξέπνευσεν is often translated “breathed his last” but it actually means literally “expelled the Spirit” (ek- is “out,” pneu– is “spirit,” and –sen makes a verb of action). Hence when the Spirit drives someone into the wilderness, Jesus has to be the movant. John’s role is so ancillary he isn’t even the subject or object of any prior relevant sentence, and certainly not the one the Spirit entered so as to impel them somewhere.
So there is no way any author here ever meant John to be the one in the wilderness. Price’s theory is just not credible. And if he had applied sound method—to thus minimize weakly evidenced epicycles to ascertain the most probable theory on extant evidence (rather than a theory he can “make fit” somehow), and then attend to the underlying Greek language and its composition and grammar, and ensure the results fit all the other evidence of why Mark is telling any of these stories (hence knowing about the role of the Spirit here, all the way to the crucifixion and back)—he would not have made any of these mistakes. And I would not have wasted hours of my life wrangling a bad theory.
I would love it if there were some allusion to Paul here. But there just isn’t. And while I noted there are problems with the Seven Loaves argument for that being a reference to Paul (an obvious inspiration to find more), those problems are far weaker, and thus unable to drown out the evidence for that conclusion—which is not rewritten or invented evidence, but the actual evidence we have.
In the Sower Parable, if Paul had said something about different yields, even used the numbers thirty, sixty, and hundred in some applicable way, for example, then we maybe could salvage something here. And hey, sure, maybe he did say that, or anything else that more directly connects to something in this parable (it need not be the numbers), in some letter we don’t have or some piece of the letters we have that hasn’t survived—but speculation is idle; don’t know is don’t know. Likewise, Price notes some correct things (the role of Ezekiel 17 here; general ideas about sowing metaphors for the mission; and so on). But none are improbable without Price’s theory, and so none are evidence for Price’s theory. And yes, I do think he may be on to something. The Peter and James & John connections are probable. So maybe there is some connection to the others we are all missing. But that doesn’t get us the rest of Price’s theory. It at best sends us on a goose chase for some other one.
And maybe it’s not a wild goose. But who knows. For example, it is true that the Satan-snatched group is associated with “the road” and that connects to John the Baptist (as he “prepares” that road and did some sort of prior preaching), but the most we can honestly say is that this would have to mean John’s preaching was ineffective, not that Satan snatched the gospel out of him—because John is the sower in that case, not the seed. And even that’s fairly weak. We are leaping here. And we don’t have the needed two or more coincidences, just one, which is not improbable enough to be sure Mark means us to connect John here at all. After all, “the road” (translated “the way”) is a motif throughout Mark, not just the John pericope; and the only character besides Jesus that Mark directly connects Satan to is Peter, not John. But not in any way that connects here. So Satan can’t have been Mark’s intended link; Satan’s role in the parable is incidental, or generic—people in general must resist his temptations as Jesus did. Or something like that. This is all not as “red string board” as what has seduced Price. But it’s still more probable on sober considerations of method.
So Price just failed on sober considerations of method.
Tomorrow I will continue with my example from D.O. Smith, and my overall Conclusion and advice.
Discover more from Richard Carrier Blogs
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.





Thanks Dr. Carrier for taking a look at this. However, I do think that you’ve give the case I present a bit of a short shrift.
As you say, there does need to be multiple corroborating points, which I do provide and in fact have come up with more.
What is important to note here is that I am absolutely proposing that the Gospel of Mark has been revised and that the current text does not align with the parable because it has been modified. The point of the analysis is to show that the canonical Gospel of Mark is not the original version of the story. So yes, there is language that does not align.
As for the parable. The case I make is that:
1. The “ones by the road where the word is sown” represent John the Baptist
2. The “ones sown on rocky places” represent Peter
3. The ones “sown among the thorns” represent James and John Zebedee
4. The “ones sown on the good ground” represent Paul
Things to note:
The first three figures mentioned here are the first three characters introduced in the story (not counting Jesus).
For John, the Parable says: “Listen! Behold, the farmer went out to sow. As he sowed, some seed fell by the road, and the birds came and devoured it.”
The explanation says: “The farmer sows the word. The ones by the road are the ones where the word is sown; and when they have heard, immediately Satan comes and takes away the word which has been sown in them.”
In the opening scene we see:
“In those days, Jesus came from Nazareth of Galilee, and was baptized by John in the Jordan. Immediately coming up from the water, he saw the heavens parting and the Spirit descending on him like a dove. A voice came out of the sky, “You are my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.”
Immediately the Spirit drove him out into the wilderness. He was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted by Satan. He was with the wild animals; and the angels were serving him.
Now after John was taken into custody, Jesus came into Galilee, preaching the Good News of God’s Kingdom, and saying, “The time is fulfilled, and God’s Kingdom is at hand! Repent, and believe in the Good News.””
So, with just the text as it sits, without any further analysis, we have the fact that the first figure in the parable talks about birds and Satan. The first character in the story (John the Baptist) is involved in a scene that also involves birds and Satan.
Furthermore, I note in the book that the words “taken into custody” or “arrested” are more properly translated as “handed over”. I then show that there are two passages in the Pauline letters that explicitly talk about handing people over to Satan using the exact same Greek word that is used here in Mark.
I further explain that in the canonical narrative the arrest of John is very strange, because it comes out of nowhere. In fact, this is what led me to the analysis to begin with. Why is John being “handed over”?
This led me to the proposed reconstruction:
“In those days, Jesus came from Nazareth of Galilee, and
wasbaptizedbyJohn in the Jordan. Immediately coming up from the water, he saw the heavens parting and the Spirit descending on him like a dove. A voice came out of the sky, “You are[This is] my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.”Immediately the Spirit drove him out into the wilderness. He was there in the wilderness forty days, tempted by Satan. He was with the wild animals; and the angels were serving him.
Now after John was taken into custody, Jesus came into Galilee, preaching the Good News of God’s Kingdom, and saying, “The time is fulfilled, and God’s Kingdom is at hand! Repent, and believe in the Good News.””
Yes, this requires that the canonical text not be original. But that is the point. The point is that the text has been changed from what it must have originally said, because with just these minor modifications we now “miraculously” end up with a narrative passage that very clearly aligns with the Parable of the Sower. Is that just coincidence?
And further, I show that in Mark 6, where the arrest of JtB is exampled, it also just “happens” to be the case that Mark 6:14 reads directly into Mark 6:30 with verses 14-29 being entirely superfluous. If verses 6:14-29 are removed from the text then chapter 6 actually reads more coherently. Is this just another coincidence?
“7 And He summoned the twelve and began to send them out in pairs, and gave them authority over the unclean spirits; 8 and He instructed them that they should take nothing for their journey, except a mere staff—no bread, no bag, no money in their belt— 9 but to wear sandals; and He added, “Do not put on two tunics.” 10 And He said to them, “Wherever you enter a house, stay there until you leave town. 11 Any place that does not receive you or listen to you, as you go out from there, shake the dust off the soles of your feet for a testimony against them.” 12 They went out and preached that men should repent. 13 And they were casting out many demons and were anointing with oil many sick people and healing them. …
30 The apostles gathered together with Jesus; and they reported to Him all that they had done and taught. 31 And He said to them, “Come away by yourselves to a secluded place and rest a while.” (For there were many people coming and going, and they did not even have time to eat.) 32 They went away in the boat to a secluded place by themselves.”
And as you acknowledge, the description of the ones sown on rocky ground very clearly aligns perfectly with the description of Peter (whose name literally means Rock). And you acknowledge the alignment with James and John.
So, what are the chances that the parable is talking about Peter and James and John (the 2nd and 3rd characters introduced in the story), but not about John the Baptist (the 1st character mentioned in the story)?
Yes, what I’m proposing is that canonical text is not original, and that is the whole point. I also link this with additional analysis in the book to show that the Gospel of Luke and John are also acknowledged by a growing number of scholars to also not be original. Luke and John also show multiple signs of having been modified by proto-orthodox writers. I further explain that Matthew is a fully recomposed version of an earlier Gospel, namely proto-Luke/Evangelion. So we have Matthew being an entirely recomposed version of earlier Gospels, we have Luke that is also derived from an earlier Gospel with added text (chapters 1-2, and other edits), and John being a revised version of an earlier Valentinian style Gospel, and now evidence that canonical Mark also is not original. So this is a consistent pattern, indicating that all of the canonical Gospels are revised versions of earlier Gospels.
Now as for Paul, yes, my proposal for Paul is somewhat speculative, but it is informed by the fact that there are multiple allusions to Paul throughout the Gospel, as I explain. This is further supported by the analysis you present about the 7 baskets, which I agree with.
Look, this is a Pauline story. There are multiple hints about Paul throughout it. Also note that the talk about bearing fruit in the parable is aligned with multiple mentions of the gospel bearing fruit in the Pauline letters.
So I do think that the case I’ve presented has more to it than you have considered. I sincerely do appreciate you taking the time to look at this. I know that what I’m proposing in many says blows up biblical scholarship as we know it. I understand that “proving” that canonical Mark is not fully original and that it has been modified from an earlier text is something that the field is not at all equipped to handle, but I think the case I’ve put together is quite strong.
Whoops I mean to change “taken into custody” to “handed over” in the reconstruction.
Are those edits as sensible in the Greek?
In some cases more so. But what is being proposed here is that modification of the original story has taken place. So, in some sense, whether this or that change is required doesn’t really matter. If someone changed 1 word they could just as easily have changed 5 words or 100. The point is the evidence for alignment with the Parable of the Sower. We can see from what is currently in the canonical text that there is a high degree of correlation between the parable and the scenes in question.
And motivations behind the proposed editing is also very clear. We know that various so-called heretics, Marcion among them, claimed that John the Baptist was a representative of the Creator and was thus an invalid figure who represented the invalid Law and Prophets that Jesus was sent to overthrow.
Thus, anyone intent or refuting such claims would have a motivation to revise the story as I have reconstructed it to show that JtB was not “invalid”.
So potential motivations behind the proposed modification are clear and well established in the literature. We can see why someone seeking to disprove such a heretical view would modify the narrative away from what I have reconstructed to what the canonical version says.
We know all these texts were changed to varying degrees, accidentally and deliberately, but the original text needs to have told a story the author could have intended. Handing the baptist the starring desert role and then tossing him aside makes no narrative sense: Jesus had to be the tale’s protagonist. In Mark’s time, his Jesus evidently still needed the baptist’s imprimatur (however awkward it later became) but nothing beyond that, so that’s all he gives us. Later, it might have been helpful to elide the baptist entirely, if it could have been achieved.
Another problem is that the birds have such utterly different meanings, any attempt at a parallel would sow only confusion. Sometimes a metaphorical road and thorn patch are just a road and thorn patch, however much else we might wish the author had attempted.
But all this is piling on. The point of the article is that, structurally, the reasoning cited undermines any case for the proposed alteration, so anything that depends on the alteration is doomed from there on.
#1 It actually does make sense as I explain in the book. #2 The implications need to be addressed separately from the evidence.
In terms of making sense, what I explain the book is that the original story, as it is revealed from the analysis of the Parable of the Sower, is a story that is decidedly pro-Pauline and highly aligned with many so-called heretical views.
John the Baptist is depicted as a prophet of the old covenant. This is aligned with the statement about JtB from Luke/Evangelion: ““The Law and the Prophets were proclaimed until John; since that time the gospel of the kingdom of God has been preached, and everyone is forcing his way into it.” So John represent the prophets of old, whose faith is depicted as inadequate, much as Moses didn’t enter in to the promised land, so too John does not enter int the Kingdom.
This again is reflected in the reconstructed scene. In addition, in Acts we see that Paul deems the baptism of John to be insufficient:
“Acts 19: 2 He said to them, “Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?” And they said to him, “No, we have not even heard whether there is a Holy Spirit.” 3 And he said, “Into what then were you baptized?” And they said, “Into John’s baptism.” 4 Paul said, “John baptized with the baptism of repentance, telling the people to believe in Him who was coming after him, that is, in Jesus.” 5 When they heard this, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus.”
Here we see John’s baptism being described as inadequate and lacking the Holy Spirit. I also note in the book that in the canonical reading the expectation is set that Jesus will be the one performing the baptism, but that instead we see Jesus being baptized by John, even though Mark 1:8 has set the expectation that Jesus will baptize in the Holy Spirit. With my reconstruction that expectation is then met as expected.
In addition, I also explain in the book that according to the reconstructed reading, JtB is never arrested and never killed in the story. This aligns with the Gospel of John. What I show in the book is that multiple aspects of the Gospel of John are aligned with the reconstructed version of the story in ways that canonical Mark are not. This indicates that the Gospel of John was derived from a pre-canonical version of Mark that looked more like the reconstructed version I propose.
In terms of the intent of the story, what I am proposing the original story said actually makes far more sense than the canonical version, its just that the original version was not orthodox in character. And that is the point, this is evidence that teh orthodox story has been derived from an earlier “heretical” text, just like Luke, John and Matthew (yes, Luke and Matthew from Evangelion or similar and John from the Valentinian Gospel or similar).
The original version of Mark, as I have reconstructed it, is very clearly against the Twelve. John and the The Twelve are all depicted negatively, as failures. The story sets the stage for Paul. The abrupt ending of Mark appears to be a product of having removed the original ending in which the risen Jesus was revealed to Paul alone, or was designed to be followed by an account of Paul’s ministry that would have begun essentially with the material we find in Acts 8.
So the original story has very clear logic to it, but it is logic that is obviously heretical. In the original story the Twelve represent the Twelve tribes of Israel, whom the Lord called to him, but who failed to understand the Lord and ended up betraying him, as described in the book of Kings. This led to the Lord’s decision to use the Babylonians as his instrument to punish Israel by having the Babylonians sack Jerusalem and destroy the temple. This is the very clear symbolism behind the story.
In the original version of Mark The Twelve represent the Twelve Tribes, who also fail to understand the Lord and end up betraying him. All of this sets the stage for the message of the Lord to be carried to the Gentiles by one man: Paul, just as one man (Josephus), carried the message to the Romans. after the Great Revolt. The story of Mark sets the stage for Paul and is all built around symbolism about the events leading up to the sacking of Jerusalem by the Romans, which is patterned on the story of Elijah and Elisha, which is the story from the Jewish scriptures that sets the stage for the sacking of Jerusalem by the Babylonians.
The case that I present is far more sophisticated that what Dr. Carrier has presented here. I’m not sure why he has chosen to misrepresent the my work here, but that’s the case. I certainly look forward to a fair assessment of the case I make, but what has been presented here is not at all a fair assessment.
I do hope that Dr. Carrier will spend more time with the material and reevaluate. I know that the case I’m presenting is radically novel and extremely challenging to a traditional understanding of the New Testament. It will take time for people to absorb it, but it is absolutely well supported. Again, I’m not sure why almost nothing of my argument from the book was presented by Dr. Carrier here. What was presented here is more just the conclusions I reached and attacking those conclusions without presenting any aspect of the case I made to support them.
You still connect a bird symbolizing the holy spirit to others representing Satan, which seems fatal to the whole concept.
This is all already refuted by my article’s points so no specific reply is needed.
But I welcome other commenters here to interact with your argument here and challenge or ask questions about it.
And if anyone besides Price wants my thoughts on a specific claim in Price’s comments, please quote the specific claim, and ask me a specific question about it. I cannot justify the burn in time to fisk it all (as I explain in the article is always the case). So you need to zero in on a few things that you yourself don’t already see the obvious irrelevance or problem with.
But you haven’t actually. You didn’t present any of the case I presented in the book. You basically invented a bunch of things and then refuted strawmen.
This is just complete and total invention. You’ve said nothing about any of the arguments I presented in favor of various points. You’re just making up numbers.
All well and good, but if someone is editing the scene, they can change the grammar however they want, so this seems to be an entirely useless point.
I provided multiple arguments in support of the reconstruction I provided and you presented none of them.
Refutation of the argument I actually put forward actually requires dismissing roughly a dozen points that I make as coincidences.
Its a coincidence that Mark 6:13 happens to read directly into Mark 6:30. Its a coincidence that swapping the baptism of Jesus and John results in a scene that now is perfectly aligned with the Parable of the Sower. Its a coincidence that the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd characters introduced in the story just happen to have scenes that align with the Parable of the Sower in perfect order. It’s a coincidence that replacing “some people” in the anointing scene with “James and John Zebedee” and replacing Judas with James shortly after happens to unite the complainer and betrayer just as the complainer and betrayer are united in the Gospel of John. And on and on, these only scratch the surface.
And its a super coincidence that all of these things just happen to the true together.
We could certainly argue about Paul. Sure, maybe the last figure mentioned in the Parable isn’t Paul. Who else would it be? I show throughout the book that the Gospel of Mark is a Pauline work, designed to further a Pauline message. I identify multiple allusions to Paul in the story. You acknowledge that the Seven Loaves is a “hidden message” about Paul. The ending is clearly abrupt and cutoff. The Pauline letters (which you acknowledge are referenced in Mark) repeatedly talk about Paul and his gospel bearing fruit.
So, who do you think the one “bearing fruit” might be?
I guess Paul is an entirely unfounded conjecture…
And its not as if this is coming out of nowhere. The church fathers alleged that multiple “heretics” claimed that The Twelve were false apostles that Paul was the only legitimate apostle. I wonder where they got that idea?
I didn’t necessarily expect you or any other scholar to hail this as a great breakthrough (someone without a PhD cannot possibly be right about anything), but I did at least expect constructive criticism instead of mocking.
Like, “Hmm, this is challenging, but X might strengthen the case” or “Interesting idea, but you didn’t account for this grammatical issue here…”
All the best.
Bad methods produce bad results, and published bad results are much more work to patch up than the methods would have been.
If ‘Mark’ meant soils to evoke specific apostles, would it matter? The only importance of anything in Mark is in what it led later churchmen to do or not do. Price had better have evidence for one or other of those, and be able to tie it back to how they read that text.
BTW: s/it’s/its/
The “would it matter” question is different than what I am addressing, be aware.
It matters in two ways:
(1) We, as historians, are obligated to do what we can to figure out the intended meanings of authors in passages like this. Just for history’s sake. This is what we are: the memory cells of society; if false memories have formed, it is our job to fix them. Just for the sake of having an accurate memory (and here that means an accurate memory of what these authors meant and thus what all this signifies about the development of an entire cultural institution still plaguing us today).
(2) Price is arguing that it is more probable that Jesus didn’t exist if we can reduce the Gospels entirely to missionary-political allegory. So he endeavors to do that. Whether he does that well is not relevant to whether it’s what he should be trying to do. His generic argument is sound. It’s only his particular arguments that are not.
I handled this differently. I sought to empirically ascertain the frequency of such texts being produced for mythical vs. historical people, which did not require the specifics Price uses, and gets ultimately the same result his would: a below middling odds this happens to historical people. I used the Rank-Raglan class because it is distinctive and countable. But that’s just a proxy for the purpose. The reference class is “heavily mythologized heroes” and Price’s missionary-political allegory model is a proper subset of that—just a different one than I used to count by.
I don’t think his gets us a countable class, which is why I didn’t use it—I only pursue his approach to remove evidence rather than stack it. For example, by explaining the mythic origin of every text in the Gospels we can show there is no evidence for historicity. Which is not the same thing as proving ahistoricity. Amateurs do confuse those a lot. But I’m not crediting Price with that confusion here. But mythicists do need to do both (add evidence for mythicism and remove evidence for historicity) but they need to do it soundly (e.g. the evidence removed does have to provably not exist and not be merely explained away; and evidence for mythicism has to be in some way more substantive than merely a lack of evidence, e.g. we need a positive model of Christian origins that makes the evidence, even its absence, more probable than otherwise, e.g. compare Historicity chapter eight and chapter nine).
I read your chapter about the spiritual body in the empty tomb and found it interesting. James tabor has a book about paul in which he agrees with you that an empty tomb isn’t necessarily required for a spiritual resurrection. He uses a great example about how the jewish community of the time could imagine a resurrection even with the previous body on a tomb: in mark, herod thinks that john resurrected when he is informed about jesus’ miracles, yet he doesn’t bother checking john’s tomb. It’s such a big problem for apologists that craig has mentioned the story in the case for christ as reincarnation, even though the text says resurrection.
Indeed.
I used to teach Sunday School. I knew the method well. If something needed explanation, one looked for a possible explanation. Having found that, it was not long until, in my mind, it became a probable explanation. And so, on Sunday, I was prepared with the explanation for that issue. I did not need to prove it was a better explanation than the alternatives. It was an explanation that made sense to me, so that is what I taught. Maybe not everybody did that, but looking back, I can certainly remember times I did that.
A lot of ministry does that (Jordon Peterson is the horrid cancerous metastasization of that): any explanation your brain thinks fits and that suits some point you want to sell is thereby “true” or true enough to claim. This differs from historians who, unlike such postmodern approaches (ironically the anti-postmodern churches are the most postmodern societies on earth), need to make logically sound evidence-based arguments to conclusions. That’s what generates knowledge rather than just-so stories.
Since the case I make in the book isn’t actually presented here, I’ll present more of it myself. In the book I start with the second figure: the ones sown on rocky ground, since that is the figure that is easiest to recognize. So I’ll just present some of that case here.
The Parable of the Sower and it’s explanation state:
Mark 4: “5 Others fell on the rocky ground, where it had little soil, and immediately it sprang up, because it had no depth of soil. 6 When the sun had risen, it was scorched; and because it had no root, it withered away.”
“16 These in the same way are those who are sown on the rocky places, who, when they have heard the word, immediately receive it with joy. 17 They have no root in themselves, but are short-lived. When oppression or persecution arises because of the word, immediately they fall away.”
In Mark 3 we read: “16 And He appointed the twelve: Simon (to whom He gave the name Peter [Petron / Πέτρον])” Petron is the literal Greek word for rock. It was never used as a name for a person prior to the 2nd century.
Thus, in Mark 3 the writer tells us that Jesus gave Simon the name Petron (Rock) and in Mark 4 Jesus describes those sown on petrōdē (rocky ground).
Now let’s see what the narrative actually says about the Rock:
Mark 8 “32 He spoke to them openly. Peter took him and began to rebuke him. 33 But he, turning around and seeing his disciples, rebuked Peter, and said, “Get behind me, Satan! For you have in mind not the things of God, but the things of men.””
Recall that the first figure in the parable is also linked to Satan. Here the writer is now linking Peter to Satan. Why might someone want to link Peter to Satan and identify him as someone who is condemned?
Galatians 2 “11 But when Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood condemned. 12 For prior to the coming of certain men from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles; but when they came, he began to withdraw and hold himself aloof, fearing the party of the circumcision. 13 The rest of the Jews joined him in hypocrisy, with the result that even Barnabas was carried away by their hypocrisy. 14 But when I saw that they were not straightforward about the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas in the presence of all, “If you, being a Jew, live like the Gentiles and not like the Jews, how is it that you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?”
And why has the writer of Mark translated the name Cephas to Petron? (Petron/petrōdē)
Further we read:
Mark 8 “34 He called the multitude to himself with his disciples and said to them, “Whoever wants to come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me. 35 For whoever wants to save his life will lose it; and whoever will lose his life for my sake and the sake of the Good News will save it. 36 For what does it profit a man to gain the whole world and forfeit his life? 37 For what will a man give in exchange for his life? 38 For whoever will be ashamed of me and of my words in this adulterous and sinful generation, the Son of Man also will be ashamed of him when he comes in his Father’s glory with the holy angels.””
In Mark 14 of course Peter is ashamed of Jesus and denies that he knows him! So this is telling us that “the Son of Man also will be ashamed of him”. Further, during the crucifixion a different Simon steps in to carry the cross of Jesus: “let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.”
Let him deny himself! Peter of course denies Jesus and is not present at the crucifixion. Can the symbolism be any more clear?
In Mark 10 we read: “31 But many who are first will be last, and the last first.””
Who was called first? Peter/Simon. Who is the last? Paul.
And of course after the arrest we read:
Mark 14 “66 As Peter was in the courtyard below, one of the maids of the high priest came, 67 and seeing Peter warming himself, she looked at him and said, “You were also with the Nazarene, Jesus!” 68 But he denied it, saying, “I neither know nor understand what you are saying.” He went out on the porch, and the rooster crowed.
69 The maid saw him and began again to tell those who stood by, “This is one of them.” 70 But he again denied it. After a little while again those who stood by said to Peter, “You truly are one of them, for you are a Galilean, and your speech shows it.” 71 But he began to curse and to swear, “I don’t know this man of whom you speak!” 72 The rooster crowed the second time. Peter remembered the words that Jesus said to him, “Before the rooster crows twice, you will deny me three times.” When he thought about that, he wept.”
So, not to recognize that the second figure described in the Parable of the Sower is talking about Peter is quite frankly absurd. Can it be any clearer?
And in 2 Corinthians we read:
2 Corinthians 11 “5 For I reckon that I am not at all behind the very best apostles. 6 But though I am unskilled in speech, yet I am not unskilled in knowledge. No, in every way we have been revealed to you in all things. 7 Or did I commit a sin in humbling myself that you might be exalted, because I preached to you God’s Good News free of charge? …
12 But what I do, that I will continue to do, that I may cut off opportunity from those who desire an opportunity, that in which they boast, they may be recognized just like us. 13 For such men are false apostles, deceitful workers, masquerading as Christ’s apostles. 14 And no wonder, for even Satan masquerades as an angel of light. 15 It is no great thing therefore if his servants also masquerade as servants of righteousness, whose end will be according to their works.”
Now, under a traditional understanding of the text we are to believe that Paul isn’t talking about Cephas, James and John here, but we know for a fact that Marcion and other heretics taught exactly that this was talking about Peter, James and John. Why were there so many heretics who taught that Paul was the only true apostle of Christ and that the Twelve were condemned Judaizers, who were led by the false apostles Peter James and John?
Well, if the original Gospel actually said this explicitly then that would explain that wouldn’t it?
What does the Hermeneia say about this?
“[T]he explanation of the rocky ground is illuminating in its reference to “tribulation or persecution on account of the world.” This detail reveals that some of those who accept the message of Jesus experienced social pressure to reject it later. This pressure may have taken many forms, anything from being ostracized to being executed.”
Now, if we are going to talk about “bad methodology” let’s talk about this statement in what is deemed to be one of the most authoritative commentaries on the Gospel of Mark. Talk about baseless speculation and total obliviousness. Not to even mention Peter is actually laughable. This is the joke that passes for “reputable scholarship”.
So, can anyone at least agree that the “ones sown on rocky ground” provide a perfect description of Peter the Rock? Or is the emperor wearing a beautiful cloak?
So, if we can at least acknowledge that the “ones sown on rocky ground” is actually describing Peter, then there are some substantial issues to address. Because if the Parable is about Peter, then its not about just random general figures. The parable is describing a figure in the story. And if the parable is describing one figure in the story, why would we not think that it is describing other figures in the story? What are the chances that the parable was about Peter, but not about anyone else in the story?
And note that (other than Jesus) Peter is the 2nd character introduced in the story. The “ones sown on rocky ground” are the 2nd figures described in the parable. Coincidence?
Who is the first character in the story? John the Baptist. Who is the 1st figure described in the parable? The ones sown on the path. The 3rd character? James and John Zebedee. The third figure in the parable? The “ones sown among the thorns”. Coincidence? This isn’t that hard.
So again, claiming that this is all just wild speculation is a real mischaracterization of what I presented in the book.
If anyone want to rebut the actual analysis I present in the book, I welcome it. But please, don’t just attack the conclusions without making counterarguments against the supporting case that I actually present in the book.
I think your theory would make more sense if James, Peter, and John where the three “so-called apostles” from Jerusalem, whose faith was found defective compared to Paul’s faith and Wisdom. It seems contrived in your theory to force John the Baptist into the first spot. If order is important then consider that James was superior to Peter making James the first to be tricked by Satan. And it was those sent by James, per Paul, who were undermining Paul’s churches.
Good attempt. Very interesting.
The order is based on the order of appearance in the narrative. And the correlations are based on the narrative itself. This isn’t just choosing things, this is aligning the parable with the descriptions of the characters. That’s how they are presented in the story.
And yes, in both Deciphering the Gospels and Cracking the New Testament I do argue that the characters in the Gospel of Mark, Peter, James and John, are based on the pillars named in Galatians, Cephas, James and John.
This position is not the traditional understanding of the text, but it is also something that a growing number of scholars recognize.
I follow most everything you say as rational, evidence based conclusions EXCEPT what I do not get is why you connect the order of the people in the parable to the order of the people appearing in the gospel as a whole. I think it is a bridge to far to equate John the Baptist to the first person in the parable of the sower MERELY because John appears first in the book. Your weakness is in that point alone and your reconstruction of the text seems to serve that weak assumption on your part.
You argue earlier that John the Baptist’s faith was weak based on two other verses. One example that you gave in this thread is where Paul corrects his followers understanding of John’s Baptism and you use that to deride John’s teaching or faith as insufficient whereas, alternatively, Paul was merely bringing his followers up to speed on what John’s baptism actually symbolized. IOW, the deficiency was not with John the Baptist’s teaching about ritual baptism but in the disciples understanding of it.
That ^^^ is one example where your argument falls apart. So just leave John the Baptist out of it, stop trying to fixate him as the first person in the parable merely because he is mentioned first in the entire book, —and everything else you say makes a lot of sense. In fact so much sense that I will likely buy your book in light of your fuller explanation on the other points. Clearly, Peter appears to align with the second person in the parable. Have you considered that the order of the people in the parable might have no significance to the author of Mark at all and that you are making more of it than he intended?
Addendum in refutation to your claim,
Per the Dead Sea Scrolls (from the original Jewish-Christians) written up to 200 BC,
This prePauline explanation of ritual baptism by the community surrounding the Teacher of Righteousness (@ 100 BC) clearly necessitates the presence of the Holy Spirit for atonement.
Refuting your assumption about John the Baptist.
The point being that if you make many bad assumptions, interpretations, reconstructions and line them all up as supporting your conclusion then the likelihood of your conclusion being true is only as strong as the sum of your individual assumptions. In this individual case, your assumption being easily refuted by a cursory read of the Dead Sea Scrolls.
Christianity can only be understood, clearly perceived, by a comprehensive review and integration of the Dead Sea Scrolls into Jewish-Christian history, as the scholar Wise has done.
Is that not what Carrier is calling for? A fresh look at Christian history in light of recent archaeological evidence?
BTW, if anyone is interested in a fuller presentation of the actual case I make in the book there are youtube videos explaining it here:
Judas Didn’t Betray Jesus… And it Changes Everything: https://youtu.be/O8KgnJtLxCM
Cracking the New Testament Overview: https://youtu.be/7SjLqZjYCNk
The first link is to a dramatic presented done by MythVision. The second is me walking through an overview of the book.
I am currently working a paper about the Parable of the Sower, which I hope to have published within a month. So, any feedback here is welcome, as this will help me to strengthen the case I’ll be presenting in the paper.
I’ll provide one more summary of the case. This is of necessity going to be a very brief overview:
1. The “ones by the road where the word is sown” represent John the Baptist
Parable: “As he sowed, some seed fell by the road, and the birds came and devoured it.”
Explanation: “The ones by the road are the ones where the word is sown; and when they have heard, immediately Satan comes and takes away the word which has been sown in them.”
Alignment:
1) 1st figure in parable, JtB is 1st character in the story.
2) The seed never takes root = this figure is not a follower.
3) Birds come – dove comes
4) Satan immediately comes – Satan immediately comes
Changes required for complete alignment:
1: Change of ἐβαπτίσθη (was baptized) to baptized (1:9).
2: Remove ὑπὸ (by) (1:9)
3: Change “You are the son of me” to “This is the son of me” (1:11).
4: Remove verses 6:14-29.
5: Maybe something else I missed
With these changes we discover a narrative about John in which he is the first figure to encounter Jesus, has the word sown in him (baptized into the Holy Spirit), is talked to by a heavenly voice, then Satan immediately comes and takes the word away from him.
Further, what this “repairs” in the story.
1) Now the expectation set in 1:8 that Jesus would be the one performing the baptism is actually met.
2) The unexplained “arrest” of Jesus is instead the handing over of John to Satan, which is explained by the prior two verses. Note that this is further supported by the Pauline letters use of “handing people over to Satan” for punishment or testing in 1 Cor 5 and 1 Tim 1.
3) The disjointed interruption of Mark 6:13 to 6:30 is explained as a later insertion.
4) The fact that JtB is never arrested in the Gospel of John is explained as having been derived from an earlier version of Mark prior to these modifications.
I also show in the book that the character of Jtb is based on Elijah. Note that this figure is driven into the wilderness for 40 days where he is tended to by angels. Elijah also goes into the wilderness for 40 days and is tended to by angels in 1 Kings 19.
2. The “ones sown on rocky places” represent Peter
Parable: “Others fell on the rocky ground, where it had little soil, and immediately it sprang up, because it had no depth of soil. When the sun had risen, it was scorched; and because it had no root, it withered away.”
Explanation: “These in the same way are those who are sown on the rocky places, who, when they have heard the word, immediately receive it with joy. They have no root in themselves, but are short-lived. When oppression or persecution arises because of the word, immediately they fall away.”
Alignment:
1) 2nd figure in parable, Peter is 2nd figure in the story (other than Jesus).
2) Rocky ground – character given the name Rock
3) Does take root = this figure is a follower
4) Immediately receives the word with joy – Peter immediately and happily follows Jesus
5) When persecution arises they fall away – Peter denies Jesus 3 times after his arrest
Changes required for complete alignment: None
Further:
Jesus calls Peter Satan directly in the narrative. Peter is replaced by a different Simon who bears the cross of Jesus. We are told that he first will be the last (Peter is the first). Jesus says he will be ashamed of those who are ashamed of him. Peter denies Jesus.
3. The ones “sown among the thorns” represent James and John Zebedee
Parable: “Others fell among the thorns, and the thorns grew up and choked it, and it yielded no fruit.”
Explanation: “These are those who have heard the word, and the cares of this age, and the deceitfulness of riches, and the desires of other things entering in choke the word, and it becomes unfruitful.”
Alignment:
1) 3rd figure in parable, James and John are the 3r characters introduced.
2) The seed does take root = these figures are followers.
3) “the desires of other things choke the word” = Mark 10: James and John express unholy desires that cause a rift between them and Jesus and the other disciples.
4) “the deceitfulness of riches” This is the tricky part. The betrayal for money.
Changes required for complete alignment:
1: Change the word “some” in Mark 14:4 to James and his brother John.
2: Change the name Judas to James everywhere in Mark 14.
3: Potentially remove verse 14:33.
Note how the anointing and betrayal reads with these changes:
Mark 14:
3 While He was in Bethany at the home of Simon the leper, and reclining at the table, there came a woman with an alabaster vial of very costly perfume of pure nard; and she broke the vial and poured it over His head. 4 But
some[James and his brother John] were indignantly remarking to one another, “Why has this perfume been wasted? 5 For this perfume might have been sold for over three hundred denarii, and the money given to the poor.” And they were scolding her. 6 But Jesus said, “Let her alone; why do you bother her? She has done a good deed to Me. 7 For you always have the poor with you, and whenever you wish you can do good to them; but you do not always have Me. 8 She has done what she could; she has anointed My body beforehand for the burial. 9 Truly I say to you, wherever the gospel is preached in the whole world, what this woman has done will also be spoken of in memory of her.”10 Then
Judas Iscariot, who was one of the twelve, [James] went off to the chief priests in order to betray Him to them. 11 They were glad when they heard this, and promised to give him money. And he began seeking how to betray Him at an opportune time.Now instead of “some people” complaining about the wasting of money, the complainer is the same person who betrays Jesus for money! And note that this is also what the Gospel of John says! Why doesn’t Mark align the complainer with the betrayer? The editor was making minimal changes so he didn’t insert Judas into the sentence because it was indicating plural complainers. When we restore James and John Zebedee, however, now the entire sentence makes sense and the whole narrative is now more coherent.
Now we have a very clear and well designed narrative from start to finish. There are only three main characters in the story, other than Jesus: Peter, James and John. Tension is built between Jesus and all three of them throughout the story. James and John demand that Jesus grant them un-grantable wishes and he denies them. After being denied power and status by Jesus, they then have an altercation with him over money. After these two rejections by Jesus, they are now motivated to betray him for money.
With these changes we discover a narrative about James and John Zebedee that is now completely aligned with the Parable of the Sower. If that just coincidence? Does it just happen to be that is we replace Judas with James that all of the sudden how the narrative “just happens” to be aligned with the Parable of the Sower?
4. The “ones sown on the good ground” represent Paul
Parable: “Others fell into the good ground and yielded fruit, growing up and increasing. Some produced thirty times, some sixty times, and some one hundred times as much.”
Explanation: “Those which were sown on the good ground are those who hear the word, accept it, and bear fruit, some thirty times, some sixty times, and some one hundred times.”
Alignment:
1) Last figure mentioned, Paul considered the last of the apostles (12+1)
2) The seed does take root = a follower
3) To bear fruit : The Pauline letters mention bearing fruit 14 times
Example: Colossians 1 3 We give thanks to God the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, praying always for you, 4 having heard of your faith in Christ Jesus and of the love which you have toward all the saints, 5 because of the hope which is laid up for you in the heavens, of which you heard before in the word of the truth of the Good News 6 which has come to you, even as it is in all the world and is bearing fruit and growing, as it does in you also, since the day you heard and knew the grace of God in truth
There are also numerous other allusions to Paul throughout the story. It is well known that the ending of Mark is highly problematic. Since at least the 3rd century there have been commentaries on the ending of Mark and ho wit was either lost or incomplete. Why is this the case?
Everything in the story indicates that the story was processing toward the revelation of Jesus to Paul. All of the stuff about Jesus revealing himself to the disciples is all later revision that was not part of the original story. The original story was designed to discredit the Twelve, and this is the analyses that proves it.
And note that according to me reconstruction of these scenes, all of the figures in the Parable are talked to by a heavenly voice: John the Baptist during the baptism, then Peter, James and John at the Transfiguration, then Paul when Jesus is revealed to him on the road to Damascus.
But please, don’t tell that what I’ve laid here, and in far more detail in the book, is just a bunch of nonsense. I think any reasonable person can see beyond that.
I certainly don’t consider your work to be a bunch of nonsense. To me, as an interested amateur, what you’ve laid out is a fascinating thought experiment that shows incredible literary imagination and a lot of effort to find hidden patterns in the text.
However, I can see the validity of Richard Carrier’s critique: as a scientific hypothesis about how Mark was originally written, it just can’t be methodologically defended. Once a theory requires, e.g., replacing Judas with James, erasing John the Baptist’s execution, or assuming a lost Pauline ending without any evidence, it feels less like historical reconstruction and more like writing a new text to fit the theory.
What you are saying is that if any changes were made to the text there would never be any way to detect them, other than finding a copy of the text that said something else.
The point of the analysis is that it uses the Parable of the Sower to confirm the proposed changes.
What has to be argued is that with just these very small proposed changed it just happens to be a coincidence that the narrative is now perfectly aligned with the Parable of the Sower.
The case against this has to be that the fact that simply swapping the baptism of Jesus and John the Baptist (which requires like 2-4 word changes) results in a scene that is now perfectly described by part 1 of the Parable of the Sower is “just chance”.
So, here is Carrier’s case:
1) The fact that swapping the baptism of Jesus and John (the 1st character in the story) results in a scene that is perfectly described by the Parable of the Sower is just chance.
2) The fact that the 2nd figure in the story (Peter/Rock) is also perfectly described by the 2nd figure in the Parable of the Sower is just chance.
3) The fact that changing the name Judas to James in Mark 14 results in the fact that the 3rd figure of the parable now perfectly describes James and John Zebedee (the 3rd characters) is just chance.
And the fact that all three of these things happen to be true together is also, just chance!
I mean, I guess I need to bust out some Bayesian calculations here, because these are some incredible odds…
I see how you are framing this in terms of probability and odds, but from my viewpoint the issue isn’t “chance”—it’s circularity. When a theory modifies the source text to fit a specific pattern—replacing Judas, removing John’s execution, or assuming a lost ending—the resulting match isn’t an astonishing coincidence or a matter of “luck.” It is the direct product of those modifications. Citing that alignment to prove the modifications just turns the argument into a circle.
But I do not plan to continue arguing here (so you can have a final word if you wish).
I could easily counter your points regarding John the Baptist but it would take too long. Instead, I propose using Paul’s own words to explain who the Mark has in mind when he composed the parable of the sower.
Who, in Paul’s own words, did he meet first among the “so-called apostles” in Jerusalem after his conversion?
Answer: James and Peter.
Therefore, Mark having before him Paul’s letters composes the parable with James and Peter in mind as those to whom Paul sowed his word, but later turned against him.
Boom!
Everything else you invent, reconstruct, and interpret in order to deride John the Baptist so that he fits your theory is merely a house of cards.
Good attempt, you forced me to think about it.
Speaking of bad methodology, you aren’t applying Bayesian theorem or probability correctly, especially since the things we are talking about are not testable and there are no modeled chances upon which to postulate anything. You can’t just make up numbers.
But your comments have given me an idea that I will incorporate into my paper. What we can look at is the number of changes required to align each periscope with the Parable of the Sower across all of the Gospels.
So what I will do is evaluate the number of changes required to align the parable to the periscope in Mark, Matthew, Luke and John. If my analysis is “just nonsense” as you claim, then what we should find is no correlation between the number of changes required and the Gospels, it should effectively be random since these passages are supposedly uncorrelated to the parable, i.e. no statistically significant difference in the number required schanges.
However, if the periscopes in Mark are correlated to the parable, when we should expect to see that the number of changes required to align the periscopes to the parable in Mark is significantly lower than the other Gospels.
So that is my hypothesis and it is testable and it will produce statistics that can be measured as significant or not.
I’m willing to take the bet. How about you?
I am totally with RG here. His analysis is clearly highly insightful, even if at points debatable. I for one think RP is inching closer than almost anyone to the most persuasive theory of why Mark wrote his (unrecognised) piece of literary genius. I note that RPs analysis of the parable of the sower builds on (and extends) the scholarly work of Mary Tolberts wonderful analysis in her book “sowing the gospel” – this books should be close to the top of the reading list for anyone who wants to understand mark. the fact that RC seems unaware of Mary’s work – and how RP is building on and deepening it (with the Paul links) is revealing to say the least.
I have lots of respect for RCs scholarship on HJ but his arrogant and flimsy dismissal of RP here is sad to behold. One has to wonder if he think his status as the top mythicist dog might be threatened?! In any case, RC has form: he often confidently asserts his views and dismisses others when they actually have a much stronger case than he allows – meta ethical subjectivism (a subject I know) is just one case in point.
And yet you give no explanation of how anything I said here is incorrect. No correcting of the probability logic or anything.
You are just emotionally invested in this. You seem to have no actual intellection of why Price’s method is invalid.
And that is precisely why we need articles like this, to arm rational observers against emotionalist rhetoric like yours, by making this about actual identifiable mistakes of fact and logic, and not “feels.”
Bayesian methodology does not require testing or modeled chances. All reasoning (including yours) is Bayesian. All the time. The only difference is whether you are actually inputting probabilities that are empirically and logically defensible, and then doing the math correctly. You are doing neither, exactly as I explain in my article.
Every claim to something having happened (like a word changed or a passage added) that you have no evidence for has a low starting probability. For example, interpolations occur at a rate of about 1 in 200 to 1 in 1000. So you need evidence that is hundreds if not thousands of times more likely on the proposed change than on any other explanation of the text.
You are doing the reverse. You are saying “it’s possible hundreds of changes occurred if only one did, therefore hundreds of changes occurred,” which is the wrong direction in probability math. Proposing a hundred changes at 50/50 apiece has a prior probability of 0.5^100 which is basically zero.
You then present conjectures and further claims without evidence “as if” it were evidence and thus falsely assign a positive likelihood ratio to all those, when in fact that entails a negative ratio.
So you can’t go around making bets when you aren’t even doing any of the math correctly.
You need to first understand how evidence works (how it changes a probability, if it does) and how conjecture works (as that is the opposite of evidence) and so on.
You need to correctly reference class your priors and correctly weigh evidence in terms of relative likelihood. And that is precisely what my article explains you are not doing.
So you can never get the “test” you want.
Sorry, but your so-called Bayesian approach is completely meaningless here. Literally what you are doing is like walking into a room with a dead person on the floor covered in blood and cuts all over them and saying, “Well, I don’t think this person was stabbed to death, because only about 1 out of 200 people carry knives on them, and the number of people killed by knife attacks each year is only 1 out of 200,000, so when you combine those chances, the odds of this being a murder by stabbing is only 0.00025%, which is highly unlikely, so this can’t be a knife attack!”
Talk about bad methodology. Your claim that “we can assume a 10% chance that the text was edited… etc. etc.” is just flat out pure and total 100% nonsense. It is the definition quackery.
And if we want to talk about “chances of a text being edited”, we can start with the fact that we now know of over 40 different ancient non-canonical Gospels. And we have four canonical Gospels. I think you are in agreement with me that every Gospel is derived from a single Gospel, the original Gospel of Mark, whatever that is. So in this case, what we can conclude is that at least about 45 out of 46 known Gospels were edited in ways that changed the meaning of various scenes. So, given that in theory every known Gospels except 1 “has been edited to change its meaning” if we’re going to throw out estimates about the likelihood of any given Gospel having been edited, that likelihood should be at least 98%!
This isn’t monkey’s typing on typewriters. We aren’t calculating the odds of lottery balls being selected here.
As I said, if you want to talk about probability, what you should be looking at is the probability that simply reversing the baptism of Jesus and John in the opening chapter would result in a periscope that then directly matches to the first figure described in the Parable of the Sower.
That is the very simple and direct probabilistic test you can apply. Because we can take any given periscope across the New Testament and you can make all kinds of changes to them, and you won’t end up with a scene that matches the Parable of the Sower.
But here, in the first scene in the Gospel, by simply reversing who baptizes who (whatever textual changes that involves) we end up with a scene that is extremely highly correlated to the first figure described in the Parable of the Sower. And I’ve already looked at all the other Gospels, and whether you use Mark’s version of the parable of their own versions of the parable (where applicable) this ONLY WORKS IN MARK! So yeah, I’ll calculate the stats, and its not even going to be close. The number of changes needed to conform Mark to the Parable are infantesicammlly small compared to any other Gospel, even Matthew.
And you want to claim that this is somehow “just nonsense”? I mean give me a complete and total break. Its laughable.
Please tell me, what are the odds that reversing who baptizes who in the opening of Mark produces a periscope that matches the 1st chapter of the Parable of the Sower?
I apologize for my tone, but I think you’ve presented a very unnecessarily harsh (and unfair) assessment of my work.
I want to clarify my position, on further thought. Where I support RPs is that the parable of the sower has symbolic meaning about the characters in the story. It is not simply – as carrier asserted – simply a “shoulder-to-the-boulder morale boosting fable.” The clearest example, as RP shows above, relates to Peter who clearly plays out the role assigned to him as seed falling on rocky ground. This analysis is not new though. IMO RP should give more credit to Mary Tolbert who in her 1987 book made a very persuasive similar (but not the same) case. Frankly, I’m surprised carrier doesn’t recognise some of this given he has done so much to highlight marks rich symbolism/literary allusions. So my criticism of carrier is that he failed to recognise this and properly engage with RPs arguments – which merit serious attention. Having said that, I’m not sure I agree with RGs specific radical interpretation of the parable – particularly the alleged links with John the Baptist (and other points). These require claims about interpolations and/ previous unknown versions of Mark, for which we don’t have any evidence (beyond the parable itself) and which seem improbable to me. Critically tolbert provides an alternative interpretation of the parables internal textual meaning which she supports with rich analysis. She basically argues that:
im not saying RG interpretation is wrong (I need to engage more with it), but I think Tolberts view seems compelling and requires less radical textual claims.
I also want to say that I’ve only just got familiar with RGs latest book and I’m pretty skeptical about his new arguments that there was no early Christian cultic movement and Paul’s letters are pure fabrication. That seems a big stretch to me. I currently am far more persuaded by “minimal mythicism” – ie carrier view. That said, I need to read RGs book before passing full judgement.
None of that is correct.
Indeed it is so far off the rails I can’t even begin to get you back on them.
Oh my lord. Here’s Carrier’s ‘claim’:
Stephanie Louise Fisher level stuff.
If you mean a hypothetical gets strawmanned into a factual and the point originally made thereby completely missed, not a bad comparison.
You are the first Biblical scholar that I am aware of who tries to use scientific methods in determining probability of a meaning being true. I am not sure your statistical methods are as airtight as you characterize it to be (for example, as it is in biomedical science which is my professional background) but at least it is a step forward for biblical scholarship challenging the field to apply some scientific rigor to the methods of interpretation. (I noticed Price’s most recent post proposes to do just that.). Kudos. As always your posts continue to add more light to the topic.
The question of “as airtight” requires unpacking.
If that means “precise” then it’s just referencing the fact that there is no biomedical precision of knowledge in history. That’s why we operate with far larger margins of error and far more frequent cases of insufficient confidence.
But if that means “there are better estimates of the probability” than I input, then you would need to present evidence for what that alternative probability is and why it’s more secure. Which is just further applying the method exactly as I call for.
Neither therefore seems to be a criticism of the method but just a description of it.
If I may ask a personal question, do you ever wish that you had chosen a different field to study rather than Biblical topics? …given that you are an atheist. I mean you could be using your analytical skills in developing a new vaccine rather than fighting the giant religious machine promoting falsehoods (eg. an alleged historical, superman Jesus of Nazareth altering the physical laws of our universe).
Dont get me wrong. I appreciate what you do, but…as an atheist? I am a theist who has motivation to try and understand what the myths in the Bible originally meant and I feel it is impossible to do so, but you as an atheist must have even less motivation to work at it. Why? You could be working in some big Pharma company or building a rocket engine…with your talent.
The Bible just seems like a waste of time sometimes…and I am a theist! Sorry if I sound down but …it should not be this difficult. Anyways, thank you for your dedication to the topic despite identifying as an atheist.
Someone has to be doing what I do. So it may as well be me. The point of civilization is division of labor. We need people developing vaccines and people fighting destructive nonsense, perfecting the methods of history, and ensuring our history does not get hijacked by lies, fantasies, and propaganda. Just as we also need artists and athletes and firefighters and clerks.
A better question is what would I be doing if all this nonsense didn’t exist and thus didn’t need someone like me (really, “us,” as I’m part of a community of experts doing this). What would I be doing then?
The answer was “theoretical physics.” Unification of quantum mechanics and relativity. Explaining the Standard Model. String theory. That is what I was training myself for until, in college, I discovered history and became involved in counter-apologetics (which I did for political reasons: Christian lies are not just obscurely defending Atlantis-style bullshit but are deployed in aid of mass murder and society-wide corruption and misery), which led to the combined focus on ancient Greco-Roman history, where I could pursue both loves (history as a historian and debunking dangerous global propaganda as a philosopher and secular humanist). I also could not afford to continue on a physics track by the time I was even able to pursue college at all (that’s vastly more expensive). And once I was invested in history as my education arc I became path dependent. There’s no going back unless I become immortal or something.
But that is “was.” My answer “now” is that because I have a massive experience and qualification base established in history I would likely be doing history of ancient science—my actual dissertation subject. I still love doing that. But it pays no bills because it fights no great societal threat. And society has chosen to disinvest in humanities. Jobs that can pay rent even in history much less ancient science are declining and so near to non-existent now, such that the market is flooded with unemployable qualified personnel, so it is a bad industry to try and get into today. Maybe if society started spending more money in these areas and actually paying “professors” living wages again. But alas. That’s not happening in my lifetime.
I should also add that I actually shifted my mission about ten years ago or so. Many might not have noticed, but I no longer (or rarely) just debunk things anymore. I turn every debunking now into a teaching tool for critical thinking, exposing the mistakes or methods used to promote bad ideas, and providing tools to catch and avoid them. Which has a broader application, just as I explain now in Part 2 of the series you are commenting on (see its conclusion where I make this explicit).
In short, if you are distracted by this being “obscure bible shit” you are missing the forest for the trees. If we can’t get “obscure bible shit” right (if we fuck that up with bad thinking, are easily seduced by bad arguments in that, and so on), then we definitely will not be getting right anything of greater importance. So we need to get this right, before we can get right things like whether we should be enduring genocide and Caribbean war crimes and massive state corruption and ICE terrorism and global-economy-destroying AI ponzi schemes and doing nothing about carbon management or watershed management or healthcare predation or massive and continuous income disparity and wage stagnation—or what to do about any of that.
The skills are transferable. But more importantly, if you lack the skills here, you will lack them in everything else. And that is the most dangerous thing on the planet right now.
So this isn’t really about bible stuff. It’s about the immiseration or salvation of humanity. The bible stuff is just the canary. It’s just the teaching tool. It’s just the first step of the staircase.
I hear you.
You are a modern day Socrates. He was among the first Greeks leading people away from religious myths and superstitions (ie., debunking myths taught as history), rather teaching a moral philosophy (probably similar to secular humanism today) From that initial person sprung thinkers like Plato, congregating in Greek universities teaching philosophy in general studying other things like nature. Consequently, the Greek civilization progressed when applying evidence and right reason to elucidate the truth of things. All because people like Socrates (and you) challenged people to think critically. History repeating itself.
First, I haven’t re-read through all of the posts, if I missed something I apologize.
This is essentially the last thing I’m going to say about this here.
You concede that the Parable describes Peter and James and John (but not for the reasons I say of course), yet deny it is about John the Baptist, and propose no other resolution to the first figure in the parable.
The only viable argument against the case I am making is that I am completely wrong and that the traditional reading is correct: the Parable has nothing to do with anyone in the story.
So if you want to argue that the Parable has no narrative symbolism and has nothing to do with anyone in the story then fine, make that argument.
But as soon as you acknowledge that the parable is about even a single character in the story, then it becomes highly implausible that it is not about any other characters in the story. The parable isn’t going to be about a mix of characters and random concepts. Either, the parable is about generic believers or it is about characters in the story.
Here is the order of the introduction of the characters in the story:
1: John the Baptist
* Jesus
2: Simon/Peter (and Andrew)
3: James and John Zebedee
The parable describes 4 types of soil/figures:
1: those on the hard path (who don’t root)
2: those on rocky ground (do root)
3: those in thorns (do root)
4: the good soil (do root)
You concede that 2 pairs with 2 and 3 pairs with 3.
So if you concede that 2 pairs with 2 and 3 pairs with 3, do you not see that it is actually less plausible to argue that 1 does not pair with 1? If 2 pairs with 2 and 3 pairs with 3, then it makes sense that 1 also pairs with 1, do you not agree?
Now if you will concede that point, you must then recognize that in order for 1 to actually pair with 1, it requires that the baptisms of Jesus and John be reversed.
So then, if we want to talk about probabilities, we must simply ask: What is more probable: that 2 pairs with 2 and 3 pairs with 3 but that 1 does not pair with 1, or that the canonical text is not the same as the text that was originally written when the parable was composed?
Now, if you believe that the Gospel of Mark was originally composed sometime between 70 and 110 (as I assume you do) and you acknowledge that the earliest potential confirmation of the canonical form of the narrative is the Diatessaron, produced around 170, then you must accept that the original narrative was composed between 100 and 60 years prior to our confirmation of the canonical form of the text.
And, given that we know of roughly 40 different non-canonical ancient versions of the Gospel story that had been produced by the end of the 3rd century, with many of those coming from the 2nd century, to believe that the original form of the story was actually transmitted completely unchanged into the hands of Tatian and Irenaeus around 170 is credulous at best! Why would anyone think that, other than taking it “on faith”?!
Why would you think that the text we have in the orthodox New Testament must indeed be the very original first version of the text, preserved exactly as “the original evangelist” penned it?
I mean, if we are going to throw out probabilities, I’ll go on the record right now and say, without even considering my own analysis of the parable, that my assumption for the probability that Irenaeus had his hands on a completely unadulterated copy of the original Gospel of Mark is *about*…. 0%. Ok, I’ll “be real” and put it at 1%.
That the proto-orthodox scriptures were transmitted faithfully from the mid-second century on I have no doubt. That what we are reading today is virtually identical to what Irenaeus read I have no doubt. What happened before 170 — that’s an entirely different story.
So yeah, if I’m going to decide what is more likely, that the Parable of the Sower is about Peter, James and John, but its not about John the Baptist, or that the canonical text is not original, I’m going with the second option all day long. And that is the whole point of my analysis. It is combining all of these different elements together, so that they stand or fall together. And once you stack all of these probabilities up together it becomes overwhelming.
What are the odds that the 2nd element of the parable is NOT talking about Peter? What value do you put there?
What are the odds that the 3rd element of the parable is NOT talking about James and John? What value do you put there?
And if the parable is likely talking about Peter, James and John, what are the odds that it is NOT talking about John the Baptist?
And again, I’ll point back to what I noted in the book about how Mark 1:6 identifies John the Baptist as Elijah, and how the the temptation scene parallels the story from 1 Kings 19 about Elijah in the wilderness being served by angels and traveling 40 days to see God. Yes, this is an inverse, and not the only inverse noted between Mark and the Elijah/Elisha narrative. Wolfgang Roth identifies multiple inversions between Mark and the Elijah/Elisha narrative in Hebrew Gospel, Cracking the Code of Mark.
So what are the odds that this scene just happens to parallel narrative elements about Elijah? Either that’s just a coincidence and has nothing to do with the Elijah/Elisha narrative (even though the scene falls smack in the middle of a bunch of other allusions to the Elijah/Elisha) or the original scene was designed for John the Baptist, who is Elijah…
….and Joshua (or Jesus) wandered in the wilderness for FORTY years before leading his “chosen ones” to the “promised land”. Therefore, the canonical narrative as it currently exists works just fine given the Hebrew types in scripture.
Simply, Gospel Jesus allegedly walked the desert for forty days just as Joshua, Son of Nun wandered the wilderness for forty years. Maybe that was Mark’s intended connection making the canonical version appear correct too.
This right here, it exemplifies the underlying problem.
That you think that is a sound inference tells me you are very bad at logic.
You appear to need hundreds of hours of 101 training in logical inference before you can do this well. And I just can’t give you that here. You are going to have to take the effort on your own to understand why what you just said is not logical. I don’t think engaging with you is worth any bother until you get at least there.
Here is my new paper on the Parable of the Sower:
https://www.academia.edu/178355451/The_Parable_of_the_Sower_as_Evidence_that_the_Gospel_of_Mark_was_Originally_a_Polemic_Against_Peter_James_and_John
The case presented here is stronger than the case presented in the book, and contains additional analysis.
You may want to skip to page 27 and hold on to your seat, because there I present the smoking gun the proves James and John Zebedee were the original betrayers. This is something that I didn’t even realize when I wrote the book, and only identified it as I went back and started working on the Greek translations.
It’s a big deal.
If that link doesn’t work try this one instead:
https://www.academia.edu/178396856/The_Parable_of_the_Sower_as_Evidence_that_the_Gospel_of_Mark_was_Originally_a_Polemic_Against_Peter_James_and_John?source=swp_share
Something isn’t working with these links, so you can delete these posts, I’ll repost when the links are working.
They appear to be working for me.
Ok, here is finally a working link to the paper. Apparently their system had flagged it for some reason and I had to contact them to get it resolved.
https://www.academia.edu/178475950/The_Parable_of_the_Sower_as_Evidence_that_the_Gospel_of_Mark_was_Originally_a_Polemic_Against_Peter_James_and_John?source=swp_share
Again, this paper put the case for my thesis way over the top.
I show definitively that the betrayal was originally written for James and John Zebedee, not Judas by connecting the scene directly back to the requests of James and John from Mark 10. Identical language is used in both scenes.